Learn / Mortgage Math · Chapter 14 of 14

Math Traps: Rounding and "Which Number Is the Base?"

The mistakes exam writers build their wrong answers from: the wrong base, the wrong rounding direction, annual vs. monthly mix-ups, and percent vs. percentage points.

The short version

Trap 1: The wrong base

Every percentage is a percent of something. Here’s the right base for each calculation:

Calculation Correct base (the “whole”) Common wrong base
LTV (purchase) Lesser of price or appraised value Whichever is higher, or the loan
Loan amount Lesser of price or appraised value Always the price
Down payment % Sales price Loan amount
Points and origination fees Loan amount Sales price
PMI / MIP Loan amount Sales price
FHA upfront MIP Base loan amount Price, or loan with the MIP already added
DTI Gross monthly income Net (take-home) income
10% tolerance limit Loan Estimate total Closing Disclosure total
ARM lifetime cap Start rate Current rate
Seller concessions Sales price (or value) Loan amount

Worked example: points on the right base

A buyer purchases a $350,000 home with 10% down and pays 2 points.

  1. Loan = $350,000 × 0.90 = $315,000
  2. Points = $315,000 × 0.02 = $6,300

Trap answer: $350,000 × 0.02 = $7,000.

Trap 2: Reverse percentages

If you know the result after a percent was taken, you divide to get back to the original. Don’t just add the percent back.

Worked example: undoing a decrease

A home sold for $190,000, which was 5% less than the original list price. What was the list price?

  1. $190,000 is 95% of the list price (100% − 5% = 95%)
  2. List price = $190,000 ÷ 0.95 = $200,000

Trap answer: $190,000 × 1.05 = $199,500.

Worked example: loan back to value

A $342,000 loan is 90% of the value. What’s the value?

  1. Value = $342,000 ÷ 0.90 = $380,000

Trap answer: $342,000 × 1.10 = $376,200.

Trap 3: Rounding in the wrong direction

Worked example: maximum loan rounds down

The maximum P&I is $1,625 and the payment factor is 6.65 per $1,000.

  1. Maximum loan = $1,625 ÷ 6.65 × 1,000 = $244,360.90
  2. The maximum loan must not go over the limit: $244,360 (rounded down to the dollar)

Worked example: break-even rounds up

Points cost $3,540 and save $75 per month.

  1. Break-even = $3,540 ÷ $75 = 47.2 months
  2. Round up: 48 months

Trap 4: LTV just over a limit

An LTV of 80.01% is over 80%. Don’t round down to squeeze under a limit.

Worked example: just over 80%

Value $300,000. Loan $240,500.

  1. LTV = $240,500 ÷ $300,000 = 0.80167
  2. 0.80167 × 100 = 80.17%, which is over 80% (PMI would typically be required on a conventional loan)

Trap 5: Annual vs. monthly

Rates, taxes, insurance premiums, and PMI rates are usually annual. Payments, income for DTI, and debts are monthly. Mixing them produces answers 12 times too big or too small.

Worked example: annual taxes in a monthly payment

P&I is $1,400. Annual taxes are $3,000. Annual insurance is $1,200.

  1. Monthly taxes = $3,000 ÷ 12 = $250
  2. Monthly insurance = $1,200 ÷ 12 = $100
  3. PITI = $1,400 + $250 + $100 = $1,750

Trap answer: $1,400 + $3,000 + $1,200 = $5,600.

Trap 6: Percent vs. percentage points

Worked example: rate increase

A 6.5% rate increases by 0.75 percentage points.

  1. New rate = 6.5% + 0.75% = 7.25%

Trap answer: 6.5% × 1.0075 = 6.549% (treating it as a 0.75% increase of 6.5%).

Trap 7: Pay frequency

Worked example: same paycheck, different schedules

A paycheck of $2,000.

  1. Biweekly monthly income = $2,000 × 26 ÷ 12 = $4,333.33
  2. Semi-monthly monthly income = $2,000 × 2 = $4,000
  3. Difference = $4,333.33 − $4,000 = $333.33 per month

Trap 8: Day counting

Worked example: February closing

A loan closes February 20 in a non-leap year. How many days of prepaid interest?

  1. Days = 28 − 20 + 1 = 9 days

A quick “sanity check” routine

Before picking an answer, ask:

  1. Is the size reasonable? Points on a $300,000 loan should be thousands, not hundreds of thousands.
  2. Did I use the right base? Loan, price, or value?
  3. Is everything in the same time unit? All monthly, or all annual?
  4. Did I round in the right direction, only at the end?

Numbers to memorize

Item Number or rule
Round break-even months Up
Round minimum income or down payment Up
Round maximum loan or payment Down
Money Nearest cent
1 percentage point 100 basis points
Biweekly periods per year 26
Semi-monthly periods per year 24

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam