The short version
- RESPA Section 8 bans giving or taking anything of value for referring settlement service business, and bans splitting fees when no real service was performed.
- Payment is fine only for services actually performed, at a reasonable price. A gift card to a real estate agent “for sending me that client” is a kickback.
- An MLO’s pay can’t be based on the loan’s terms (like the rate), and an MLO can’t be paid by both the borrower and the lender on the same loan (dual compensation).
- An MLO can’t steer a borrower into a loan to earn more money unless the loan is in the borrower’s interest.
RESPA Section 8: no kickbacks, no unearned fees
The Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), carried out by Regulation X (12 CFR 1024), covers most home loans (called “federally related mortgage loans”).
What’s banned
- Section 8(a): kickbacks for referrals. No person may give or accept any fee, kickback, or thing of value under an agreement or understanding that settlement service business will be referred.
- Section 8(b): unearned fees (fee splitting). No person may give or accept any portion, split, or percentage of a settlement charge other than for services actually performed.
“Settlement services” include originating the loan, appraisals, credit reports, title work and insurance, surveys, inspections, closing services, and real estate agent services.
“Thing of value” is broad
Money, gifts, gift cards, trips, meals, tickets, paying someone’s bills or advertising costs, free office space, discounts, increased equity in a business, and the opportunity to earn referrals. Nothing is too small to count if it’s tied to referrals.
What’s a “referral”?
Under Regulation X, a referral is any oral or written action directed to a person that has the effect of affirmatively influencing that person’s choice of a settlement service provider, when that person will pay for the service. Handing a borrower a card and saying “use this title company” is a referral.
What’s allowed
- Payment for services actually performed or goods actually furnished, at a price reasonably related to their value. Example: paying a real estate agent’s company for renting office space at market rate.
- Affiliated business arrangements that follow the rules (see below)
- Normal promotional and educational activities that aren’t conditioned on referrals and don’t pay costs the referral source would otherwise have to pay. Example: hosting an open educational seminar for agents with light refreshments.
- A company paying its own employees for generating business
- Cooperative brokerage arrangements between real estate agents and brokers
Co-marketing
If an MLO and a real estate agent share an advertisement, each must pay their proportional share of the cost. If the MLO pays the agent’s share, that’s a thing of value given for referrals.
Penalties
- Criminal: a fine of up to $10,000, up to 1 year in prison, or both, per violation
- Civil: the violator is liable to the borrower for 3 times the amount of the settlement service charge (treble damages), plus court costs and attorney’s fees
RESPA Section 9: no required title company
A seller may not require the buyer, as a condition of the sale, to buy title insurance from a particular title company. The seller can be liable for 3 times the title insurance charges. (This is a form of coercion; see the next chapter.)
Affiliated business arrangements (AfBAs)
An AfBA exists when a person in a position to refer settlement business (like a real estate brokerage or a lender) owns more than 1% of a settlement provider (say, a title company) and refers business to it. It’s legal if:
- The borrower gets the AfBA disclosure at or before the time of the referral, showing the relationship and estimated charges
- The borrower isn’t required to use the affiliate (with narrow exceptions: a lender may require its own attorney, credit reporting agency, or appraiser)
- The only thing of value received from the arrangement, other than payments for services actually performed, is a return on ownership interest (not payments tied to the number of referrals)
Loan originator compensation rules (Regulation Z §1026.36)
These TILA rules, added after the Dodd-Frank Act, control how an MLO gets paid.
No pay based on loan terms
An MLO’s compensation may not be based on the terms of the transaction (such as the interest rate, APR, or loan product) or on a proxy for a term. Paying an MLO more for a higher rate, or for selling a prepayment penalty, is banned.
Allowed: pay based on a fixed percentage of the loan amount (the regulation allows minimums and maximums), a salary or hourly wage, or the number of loans closed.
No dual compensation
If the MLO (or the MLO’s company, such as a mortgage broker) receives compensation directly from the consumer, then no one else (such as the lender) may compensate the MLO or broker for that loan. It’s one or the other: borrower-paid or lender-paid.
Changing pay after the fact: limited
An MLO’s compensation generally can’t be changed on a loan-by-loan basis to reflect the loan’s terms. One exception: compensation may be reduced to cover an unforeseen increase in an actual settlement cost above what was estimated. A company can’t routinely cut MLO pay to fund pricing concessions it negotiates with borrowers.
No steering
An MLO may not steer a consumer into a loan in order to get greater compensation, unless that loan is in the consumer’s interest.
Safe harbor: For each type of loan the borrower is interested in (fixed, adjustable, reverse), the MLO presents options from a significant number of the creditors it regularly works with, including:
- The loan with the lowest interest rate
- The loan with the lowest rate without risky features (no negative amortization, prepayment penalty, interest-only payments, balloon in the first 7 years, demand feature, or shared equity/appreciation)
- The loan with the lowest total dollar amount of discount points, origination points, and origination fees
Qualification and identification
The same rule requires loan originator organizations to make sure their MLOs are licensed or registered as required, and requires the MLO’s name and NMLS ID on the application, note, and security instrument.
Fee changes and closing cost scenarios
- A fee increase that isn’t justified by a valid changed circumstance violates TRID tolerances and may be unfair or deceptive.
- Adding fees at closing that weren’t disclosed (“junk fees” like a new “document preparation” charge) is both a tolerance problem and an ethics problem.
- Marking up a third-party fee (charging more than the provider billed and keeping the difference) can be an unearned fee under Section 8(b).
- Paying a borrower’s closing costs through a lender credit is fine when disclosed on the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| RESPA Section 8 criminal fine | Up to $10,000 per violation |
| RESPA Section 8 prison | Up to 1 year |
| RESPA Section 8 civil liability | 3 times the charge |
| RESPA Section 9 seller liability | 3 times the title insurance charges |
| AfBA ownership threshold | More than 1% |
| AfBA disclosure | At or before the referral |
| Steering safe harbor: loan options | 3 (lowest rate, lowest rate with no risky features, lowest points and fees) |
| Balloon counted as a risky feature | Balloon in the first 7 years |
Memory tricks
- “If you didn’t do the work, you don’t get the pay.” That’s Section 8(b).
- “Refer for free.” You can refer anyone you like, but you can’t get paid for it.
- “One wallet only” for dual compensation: the borrower’s wallet or the lender’s wallet, never both.
- “Pay on the amount, not the rate.” A percentage of the loan amount is OK; a bonus for a higher rate is not.
Watch out on the exam
- Small gifts still count. A $25 gift card per closed referral is a kickback.
- “The real estate agent performed no services but got a fee from the lender.” That’s an unearned fee.
- Referring is legal; getting paid for it isn’t. An MLO can recommend a title company, but can’t accept anything for it.
- Paying an MLO based on loan amount is allowed. Based on the rate or product, not allowed.
- Dual compensation question: If the borrower pays the broker directly, the lender can’t also pay the broker.
- AfBA disclosure timing: at or before the referral, not within 3 business days of application.
- Section 9 is about the seller requiring a specific title insurer.