The short version
- Two main fair lending laws: the Fair Housing Act (FHA, part of the Civil Rights Act of 1968) and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA).
- Disparate treatment = treating people differently because of a protected characteristic (intentional or not). Disparate impact = a neutral-looking policy that hurts a protected group more and isn’t justified by a legitimate business need.
- Redlining = refusing or limiting loans in an area because of the race or national origin of the people who live there. Steering = pushing borrowers toward worse products or certain neighborhoods based on a protected characteristic (or to earn more pay).
- Coercion = forcing a borrower to use a particular provider or product. Borrowers get to choose.
Protected classes
| Fair Housing Act (HUD enforces) | ECOA / Regulation B (CFPB and others enforce) |
|---|---|
| Race | Race |
| Color | Color |
| Religion | Religion |
| National origin | National origin |
| Sex | Sex |
| Familial status (families with children under 18, pregnant women) | Marital status |
| Handicap (disability) | Age (if old enough to sign a contract) |
| Receipt of public assistance income | |
| Good-faith exercise of rights under the Consumer Credit Protection Act |
The Fair Housing Act covers housing-related transactions, including mortgage lending. ECOA covers all credit.
Types of discrimination
Disparate treatment
Treating an applicant differently because of a protected characteristic.
- Overt: openly discriminatory. “We don’t make loans to people on public assistance.”
- Comparative: treating similar applicants differently. An MLO spends an hour helping one applicant fix application problems but gives a similarly qualified applicant of a different race just a denial letter. Or quotes higher fees to older applicants.
Disparate treatment doesn’t require bad intent or prejudice. Treating people differently is enough.
Disparate impact
A policy that looks neutral and is applied to everyone equally but disproportionately harms a protected group, and either isn’t justified by a legitimate business need or has a less discriminatory alternative that would work.
Example: a lender refuses to make any loan under a certain dollar amount. If that policy excludes a disproportionate number of applicants of a particular race or national origin and there’s no valid business reason, it could be disparate impact.
Prohibited practices
Redlining
Refusing to lend, or offering worse terms, in certain geographic areas because of the race, color, national origin, or other protected characteristic of the residents. The name comes from lenders literally drawing red lines on maps around minority neighborhoods.
Reverse redlining
Targeting a protected group or neighborhood with predatory, high-cost loans, rather than denying credit. Both are illegal.
Steering
Guiding a borrower toward a particular loan product or neighborhood because of a protected characteristic. Example: offering subprime loans to Hispanic borrowers who qualify for prime loans. Steering also includes steering for compensation (see the previous chapter).
Discouragement
Discouraging someone from applying, orally or in writing, because of a protected characteristic. Telling someone “You probably won’t qualify, don’t bother” based on their accent is illegal even if no application is ever taken.
Discriminatory advertising
Ads that indicate a preference or limitation based on a protected class, or marketing that only reaches certain groups to exclude others.
Coercion
Coercion is pressuring or forcing a borrower (or another party) into a choice that should be theirs:
- Requiring the borrower to use a particular settlement provider (except the narrow exceptions under RESPA for a lender’s own attorney, credit bureau, or appraiser). If the provider is an affiliate, the borrower must get the AfBA disclosure and be told they’re not required to use it.
- A seller requiring a particular title company (RESPA Section 9)
- Tying: making loan approval depend on buying another product, like insurance from a certain company
- Pressuring an appraiser to hit a value (appraiser coercion; see below)
- Pressuring a borrower to sign quickly without reading, or to accept a loan they don’t understand
Appraiser conflicts of interest
Under Regulation Z §1026.42:
- An appraiser can’t have a direct or indirect interest (financial or otherwise) in the property or transaction.
- No one, including the MLO, may coerce, bribe, or pressure the appraiser toward a value.
- The MLO may ask the appraiser to consider more information, explain the value, or fix factual errors.
- Loan production staff shouldn’t select, pay, or manage appraisers directly. That’s why many lenders use appraisal management companies (AMCs) or a separate department.
Fair treatment in practice
- Offer every applicant the same information, time, and help.
- Use the same standards for everyone when deciding whether to take an application or grant an exception.
- Document reasons for decisions.
- Don’t guess a borrower’s qualifications based on appearance, name, accent, neighborhood, or age.
- Accept applications from anyone who wants to apply. An MLO can’t refuse to take an application because of a protected characteristic.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| Fair Housing Act protected classes | 7 |
| ECOA protected characteristics | 9 |
| Fair Housing Act familial status | Children under 18 (and pregnant women) |
Memory tricks
- Fair Housing Act: “Rich Cats Rarely Nap So Fat Hamsters” = Race, Color, Religion, National origin, Sex, Familial status, Handicap.
- ECOA adds “MAP-G”: Marital status, Age, Public assistance, Good-faith exercise of rights (and drops familial status and handicap).
- Redlining = a map. Steering = a person. Redlining is about where you live; steering is about where you’re pushed.
- Treatment = “I treated them differently.” Impact = “My rule hurt them more.”
Watch out on the exam
- Disparate treatment doesn’t need bad intent. “The MLO didn’t mean to” isn’t a defense.
- Disparate impact starts with a neutral policy. If the question describes an equal rule applied to everyone with an unequal result, think disparate impact.
- Age is protected under ECOA, but a lender may consider age in a credit-scoring system that meets the rules, or to favor an applicant 62 or older. The trap is refusing an older applicant because “they might not live long enough.”
- Familial status and disability are Fair Housing Act categories, not ECOA. Marital status, age, and public assistance are ECOA, not the Fair Housing Act.
- Reverse redlining is targeting for bad loans, not refusing loans.
- “The borrower must use our affiliated title company.” That’s coercion and violates RESPA (unless it falls in one of the narrow exceptions).