Learn / Ethics · Chapter 2 of 5

Fair Lending: Discrimination, Redlining, Steering, and Coercion

Who is protected under the Fair Housing Act and ECOA, the difference between disparate treatment and disparate impact, and the prohibited practices of redlining, reverse redlining, steering, and coercion.

The short version

Protected classes

Fair Housing Act (HUD enforces) ECOA / Regulation B (CFPB and others enforce)
Race Race
Color Color
Religion Religion
National origin National origin
Sex Sex
Familial status (families with children under 18, pregnant women) Marital status
Handicap (disability) Age (if old enough to sign a contract)
Receipt of public assistance income
Good-faith exercise of rights under the Consumer Credit Protection Act

The Fair Housing Act covers housing-related transactions, including mortgage lending. ECOA covers all credit.

Types of discrimination

Disparate treatment

Treating an applicant differently because of a protected characteristic.

Disparate treatment doesn’t require bad intent or prejudice. Treating people differently is enough.

Disparate impact

A policy that looks neutral and is applied to everyone equally but disproportionately harms a protected group, and either isn’t justified by a legitimate business need or has a less discriminatory alternative that would work.

Example: a lender refuses to make any loan under a certain dollar amount. If that policy excludes a disproportionate number of applicants of a particular race or national origin and there’s no valid business reason, it could be disparate impact.

Prohibited practices

Redlining

Refusing to lend, or offering worse terms, in certain geographic areas because of the race, color, national origin, or other protected characteristic of the residents. The name comes from lenders literally drawing red lines on maps around minority neighborhoods.

Reverse redlining

Targeting a protected group or neighborhood with predatory, high-cost loans, rather than denying credit. Both are illegal.

Steering

Guiding a borrower toward a particular loan product or neighborhood because of a protected characteristic. Example: offering subprime loans to Hispanic borrowers who qualify for prime loans. Steering also includes steering for compensation (see the previous chapter).

Discouragement

Discouraging someone from applying, orally or in writing, because of a protected characteristic. Telling someone “You probably won’t qualify, don’t bother” based on their accent is illegal even if no application is ever taken.

Discriminatory advertising

Ads that indicate a preference or limitation based on a protected class, or marketing that only reaches certain groups to exclude others.

Coercion

Coercion is pressuring or forcing a borrower (or another party) into a choice that should be theirs:

Appraiser conflicts of interest

Under Regulation Z §1026.42:

Fair treatment in practice

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
Fair Housing Act protected classes 7
ECOA protected characteristics 9
Fair Housing Act familial status Children under 18 (and pregnant women)

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam