The short version
- Predatory lending means using unfair, deceptive, or abusive loan terms or tactics that benefit the lender or MLO at the borrower’s expense. Classic tactics: equity stripping, loan flipping, packing, and steering.
- UDAAP stands for unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices. The Dodd-Frank Act bans them for anyone offering consumer financial products, and the CFPB enforces it.
- Unfair = substantial injury the consumer can’t reasonably avoid, not outweighed by benefits. Deceptive = misleading to a reasonable consumer, and material. Abusive = taking unreasonable advantage of a consumer’s lack of understanding, inability to protect themselves, or reliance on you.
- An act can follow every technical disclosure rule and still be a UDAAP.
Predatory lending tactics
| Tactic | What it is | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Equity stripping | Making a loan based on the home’s equity rather than the borrower’s ability to repay, expecting the borrower to fail so the lender profits from fees or takes the home | Lending to a retiree with a paid-off house and low income, knowing they can’t make the payments |
| Loan flipping | Repeatedly refinancing a borrower, charging fees each time, with no real benefit to the borrower | Refinancing the same borrower three times in two years, each time adding points and fees |
| Packing | Adding unnecessary or unwanted extra products to the loan, often without clear explanation | Financing single-premium credit life insurance or other add-ons into the loan amount |
| Steering | Pushing a borrower into a worse or more expensive loan than they qualify for | Putting a prime borrower into a subprime loan for a bigger payout |
| Reverse redlining | Targeting minority or elderly neighborhoods with high-cost loans | Door-to-door marketing of high-fee refinances in one neighborhood |
| Bait and switch | Advertising or quoting one set of terms and delivering worse ones at closing | Quoting a fixed rate, then presenting ARM documents at the table |
| Excessive fees | Charging fees far above the market or for no real service | Multiple “processing,” “admin,” and “doc prep” fees |
| Falsifying applications | Inflating income or assets on the borrower’s behalf to push a loan through | An MLO “adjusting” the income figure so the DTI fits |
| Abusive terms | Balloon payments, negative amortization, or large prepayment penalties the borrower doesn’t understand | A short-term balloon the borrower was never told about |
Federal rules that fight predatory lending
These are covered in the Federal Law section. Here’s how they connect:
- Ability-to-repay (ATR) rule: lenders must verify the borrower can repay (stops equity stripping).
- HOEPA (Home Ownership and Equity Protection Act): extra restrictions and disclosures for high-cost mortgages, including required pre-loan counseling and bans on many abusive terms. The dollar and rate thresholds are adjusted every year; check the Federal Law section for the current year.
- Single-premium credit insurance ban: Regulation Z prohibits financing single-premium credit insurance into closed-end loans secured by a dwelling (stops a common form of packing).
- Anti-steering and LO compensation rules (Regulation Z §1026.36)
- Higher-priced mortgage loan (HPML) rules: required escrows and appraisal protections
Net tangible benefit
A refinance should leave the borrower better off: a lower rate or payment, a shorter term, moving from an ARM to a fixed rate, or cash for a real need. Many states and loan programs require a documented net tangible benefit, and it’s the best test for spotting loan flipping.
UDAAP
Where it comes from
- Dodd-Frank Act (Title X) makes it illegal for any covered person or service provider to commit unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices in connection with consumer financial products. The CFPB enforces it; state attorneys general can too.
- The older FTC Act, Section 5 already banned unfair or deceptive acts or practices (UDAP). Dodd-Frank added abusive.
The three tests
Unfair. An act is unfair when:
- It causes or is likely to cause substantial injury to consumers,
- The injury is not reasonably avoidable by consumers, and
- The injury is not outweighed by benefits to consumers or competition.
Deceptive. An act is deceptive when:
- A representation, omission, or practice misleads or is likely to mislead the consumer,
- The consumer’s interpretation is reasonable under the circumstances, and
- The misleading information is material (it would affect the consumer’s decision).
Abusive. An act is abusive when it:
- Materially interferes with the consumer’s ability to understand a term or condition, or
- Takes unreasonable advantage of:
- the consumer’s lack of understanding of the product’s risks, costs, or conditions,
- the consumer’s inability to protect their interests in choosing or using the product, or
- the consumer’s reasonable reliance on the company to act in their interests.
UDAAP examples in mortgage lending
- Advertising “no closing costs” when the costs are just rolled into the loan without saying so (deceptive)
- Telling a borrower a rate is locked when it isn’t (deceptive)
- Charging fees for services never provided (unfair)
- Pushing an elderly borrower with limited English into a complex loan and hurrying them past the terms (abusive)
- Burying a large balloon payment in the fine print and telling the borrower “it’s standard” (abusive and deceptive)
- Misrepresenting a lender as affiliated with a government agency (deceptive, also a Regulation Z and MAP rule violation)
Advertising honesty
Truthful advertising is an ethical duty, not just a technical rule:
- Advertise only terms you actually offer, to borrowers who can realistically get them.
- Disclose conditions: if the rate requires paying points or excellent credit, say so.
- Don’t call a pre-qualification a pre-approval, or promise approval (“guaranteed approval!”).
- Don’t use fake urgency (“rates go up tomorrow!”) unless it’s true.
- Don’t disguise a solicitation as a message from the borrower’s current lender or a government agency.
See the origination chapter on advertising for Regulation Z’s triggering-term rules.
Memory tricks
- The predatory trio: “Strip, Flip, Pack.” Strip the equity, flip the loan, pack the extras.
- Unfair = “Injured, Unavoidable, Unbalanced.”
- Deceptive = “Misleading, Reasonable, Material” (MRM).
- Abusive = “Took advantage.” The abusive test is about exploiting the consumer’s confusion, helplessness, or trust.
- UDAP (FTC) vs. UDAAP (Dodd-Frank): the extra “A” is abusive.
Watch out on the exam
- Loan flipping is about repeated refinances. Property flipping (buying and quickly reselling with an inflated appraisal) is a fraud scheme, covered in the next chapter.
- Equity stripping focuses on equity, not ability to repay. The tip-off in a question: lots of equity, little income.
- Packing = adding products, like credit insurance or unnecessary services.
- Disclosed doesn’t mean fair. A practice can be disclosed on the forms and still be abusive or unfair.
- “Abusive” was added by Dodd-Frank; the FTC Act’s older standard covers only unfair or deceptive.
- Deceptive requires materiality. A trivial misstatement that wouldn’t affect anyone’s decision isn’t deceptive.