The short version
- Mortgage fraud is a material misstatement, misrepresentation, or omission that a lender relies on to make a loan. Lying on a loan application is a federal crime.
- Know the big schemes: occupancy fraud, straw buyers, air loans, identity fraud, appraisal fraud, income, employment, and asset fraud, and illegal property flipping.
- Non-bank mortgage lenders and originators must have an anti-money laundering (AML) program and file a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) for suspicious transactions of $5,000 or more, within 30 calendar days of detecting the activity.
- Never tell anyone involved that a SAR has been or will be filed.
Two motives: fraud for housing and fraud for profit
| Fraud for housing (property) | Fraud for profit | |
|---|---|---|
| Who | Usually the borrower | Often industry insiders (MLOs, appraisers, agents, closing agents) working together |
| Goal | To buy or keep a home | To steal money or equity |
| Example | Overstating income to qualify for a house they want to live in | A ring using straw buyers and inflated appraisals to pull cash out of properties |
Both are crimes.
Common fraud schemes
Occupancy fraud
Claiming the property will be a primary residence when it’s really an investment or second home, to get a lower rate, a smaller down payment, or better terms.
Red flags: the borrower keeps a larger or nicer current home and plans to “rent it out”; the new home is far from the borrower’s job; the borrower already owns several properties; mail and bank statements still go to the old address; a tenant already lives in the “primary residence.”
Straw buyer
Someone with good credit (the “straw”) lends their name and credit to the loan for a person who couldn’t qualify or wants to hide their involvement. The straw usually never intends to live there or make payments, and may be paid a fee.
Red flags: the borrower seems unfamiliar with the property or the deal; someone else attends meetings and does all the talking; the borrower’s income, age, or lifestyle doesn’t fit the property; a quitclaim deed to another person soon after closing.
Air loan
A loan on a property or borrower that doesn’t exist. Fraudsters invent the borrower, the property, the employer, and sometimes the appraiser, often using fake phone lines answered by accomplices.
Red flags: the property can’t be found on maps or in tax records; phone numbers for the employer, landlord, and borrower go to the same place; documents look template-generated.
Identity fraud
Using a stolen or synthetic identity (a mix of real and fake information, such as a real SSN with a made-up name) to get a loan.
Red flags: an SSN issued before the borrower was born or that belongs to a deceased person; a credit history much shorter than the borrower’s age suggests; inconsistent addresses; ID that looks altered; a fraud alert on the credit report.
Appraisal fraud
Inflating (or sometimes deflating) the property’s value, often with the help of a dishonest appraiser. Inflated values support bigger loans in flipping and cash-out schemes.
Red flags: comps far away, old, or not really comparable; big unexplained adjustments; value exactly at the contract price with thin support; photos that don’t match; the property sold recently for much less; the MLO or agent “pre-selected” the appraiser.
Income and employment fraud
Overstating income or inventing a job. Includes fake paystubs and W-2s, fictitious employers, and “verification” phone numbers that go to a friend.
Red flags: paystub math doesn’t work (year-to-date doesn’t match pay period × periods); round numbers; no taxes withheld; employer only has a P.O. box or cell phone; W-2 wages don’t match IRS transcripts; the borrower’s stated job doesn’t fit their education or age; self-employed income that jumped suddenly.
Asset fraud
Faking or borrowing the money for the down payment and reserves: altered bank statements, undisclosed loans disguised as gifts, or temporarily “renting” someone else’s assets.
Red flags: large recent deposits with no source; balances that don’t match the transaction history; a gift letter from someone with no clear relationship or from an interested party (like the seller); funds that disappear right after closing.
Illegal property flipping
Buying a property cheap and reselling it quickly at an inflated price supported by a fraudulent appraisal, often to a straw buyer. (Legitimately fixing up and reselling a home isn’t fraud. The fraud is the inflated value and false documents.)
Red flags: a recent prior sale at a much lower price; little or no renovation to justify the jump; the seller has owned it only briefly; non-arm’s-length relationships among buyer, seller, and agent. (Recall the HPML rule requiring a second appraisal for certain quick resales.)
Other schemes to recognize
- Silent second: the buyer secretly borrows the down payment (often from the seller) and hides it from the first lender
- Cash back at closing: a hidden payment to the buyer or a third party, funded by an inflated price
- Shotgunning: getting multiple loans on the same property from different lenders at the same time, before any are recorded
- Foreclosure rescue scams: “rescuers” promise to save a struggling homeowner’s house but trick them into signing over the deed or equity
- Equity skimming: a buyer takes over a property, collects rent, but doesn’t pay the mortgage
- Builder bailout: a builder hides incentives (like paying the buyer’s down payment) to move unsold homes, inflating the true price
General red flags in the sales contract and application
- The seller isn’t the owner of record
- Contract addenda that raise the price, add cash back, or transfer money to unrelated parties
- Non-arm’s-length deals (buyer and seller related, or the agent is the buyer) that weren’t disclosed
- Handwritten or whited-out changes on documents
- The borrower is unusually rushed or insists on a specific appraiser, title company, or closing agent
- A third party controls the borrower’s documents or communication
- A borrower who says “Just put whatever makes it work”
The MLO’s responsibility
- Verify application information. Don’t accept documents at face value when something doesn’t fit.
- Never alter documents, “coach” a borrower on what to say, or ignore information that changes the picture.
- If the MLO learns material information (a new debt, a job loss, a different occupancy plan) at any point before closing, it must go to the underwriter.
- Escalate suspicious activity to the company’s compliance or BSA officer. The company decides whether to file a SAR.
- MLOs who participate in fraud face license revocation and criminal prosecution.
Criminal penalties
The URLA warns borrowers that false statements can be a federal crime. Knowingly making a false statement on a loan application to a federally insured institution is punishable by up to $1,000,000 in fines and 30 years in prison (18 U.S.C. §1014).
Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs)
Who must file
Since 2012, FinCEN’s rules under the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) treat non-bank residential mortgage lenders and originators (RMLOs) as “loan or finance companies.” They must:
- Have a written anti-money laundering (AML) program (policies, a compliance officer, training, and independent testing)
- File SARs with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN)
(Banks and credit unions have their own SAR rules.)
When to file
A SAR is required for a transaction conducted by, at, or through the company that involves or adds up to at least $5,000 in funds or other assets, if the company knows, suspects, or has reason to suspect the transaction:
- Involves funds from illegal activity or is meant to hide them (money laundering)
- Is designed to evade BSA reporting requirements
- Has no business or apparent lawful purpose, and there’s no reasonable explanation after looking at the facts
- Uses the company to facilitate criminal activity (this includes mortgage fraud)
Deadlines and rules
- File no later than 30 calendar days after initial detection of facts that may be the basis for a SAR.
- If no suspect has been identified, the company may take another 30 days to identify one, but in no case more than 60 days after initial detection.
- Confidential: The company and its employees may not tell anyone involved in the transaction that a SAR has been filed. Disclosure is limited to FinCEN, law enforcement, and regulators.
- Keep a copy of the SAR and supporting documents for 5 years from the filing date.
- Filers have safe harbor protection from civil liability for filing.
- Ongoing violations that need immediate attention (like a fraud in progress): also call law enforcement right away.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| SAR threshold for RMLOs | $5,000 or more |
| SAR filing deadline | 30 calendar days after initial detection |
| Extension if no suspect identified | Another 30 days, maximum 60 days total |
| SAR record retention | 5 years |
| False statement on a loan application (18 U.S.C. §1014) | Up to $1,000,000 fine and 30 years in prison |
Memory tricks
- “Five, thirty, sixty, five”: $5,000 threshold, 30 days to file, 60 days max, keep 5 years.
- SAR = “Silence And Report.” Report it, and don’t tell the subject.
- Air loan = “nothing but air.” No real borrower, no real property.
- Straw buyer = “scarecrow.” A figure standing in for someone else.
- Occupancy fraud = “I’ll live there” (but won’t).
Watch out on the exam
- Tipping off is illegal. Any answer where the MLO tells the borrower “we’re filing a report on you” is wrong.
- The MLO usually doesn’t file the SAR personally. The MLO reports internally to compliance or the BSA officer, and the company files.
- Illegal property flipping vs. loan flipping. Property flipping = inflated resale value. Loan flipping = repeated refinances for fees.
- A gift from the seller is a red flag for a hidden price reduction or silent second.
- “The borrower said the income is right, so the MLO can ignore the tax transcript.” No. Discrepancies must be resolved.
- Occupancy matters because terms differ. Investment property loans cost more, which is the fraudster’s motive.