Learn / Ethics · Chapter 4 of 5

Mortgage Fraud: Schemes, Red Flags, and Suspicious Activity Reports

The common mortgage fraud schemes, the red flags that give them away, and how and when a Suspicious Activity Report must be filed.

The short version

Two motives: fraud for housing and fraud for profit

Fraud for housing (property) Fraud for profit
Who Usually the borrower Often industry insiders (MLOs, appraisers, agents, closing agents) working together
Goal To buy or keep a home To steal money or equity
Example Overstating income to qualify for a house they want to live in A ring using straw buyers and inflated appraisals to pull cash out of properties

Both are crimes.

Common fraud schemes

Occupancy fraud

Claiming the property will be a primary residence when it’s really an investment or second home, to get a lower rate, a smaller down payment, or better terms.

Red flags: the borrower keeps a larger or nicer current home and plans to “rent it out”; the new home is far from the borrower’s job; the borrower already owns several properties; mail and bank statements still go to the old address; a tenant already lives in the “primary residence.”

Straw buyer

Someone with good credit (the “straw”) lends their name and credit to the loan for a person who couldn’t qualify or wants to hide their involvement. The straw usually never intends to live there or make payments, and may be paid a fee.

Red flags: the borrower seems unfamiliar with the property or the deal; someone else attends meetings and does all the talking; the borrower’s income, age, or lifestyle doesn’t fit the property; a quitclaim deed to another person soon after closing.

Air loan

A loan on a property or borrower that doesn’t exist. Fraudsters invent the borrower, the property, the employer, and sometimes the appraiser, often using fake phone lines answered by accomplices.

Red flags: the property can’t be found on maps or in tax records; phone numbers for the employer, landlord, and borrower go to the same place; documents look template-generated.

Identity fraud

Using a stolen or synthetic identity (a mix of real and fake information, such as a real SSN with a made-up name) to get a loan.

Red flags: an SSN issued before the borrower was born or that belongs to a deceased person; a credit history much shorter than the borrower’s age suggests; inconsistent addresses; ID that looks altered; a fraud alert on the credit report.

Appraisal fraud

Inflating (or sometimes deflating) the property’s value, often with the help of a dishonest appraiser. Inflated values support bigger loans in flipping and cash-out schemes.

Red flags: comps far away, old, or not really comparable; big unexplained adjustments; value exactly at the contract price with thin support; photos that don’t match; the property sold recently for much less; the MLO or agent “pre-selected” the appraiser.

Income and employment fraud

Overstating income or inventing a job. Includes fake paystubs and W-2s, fictitious employers, and “verification” phone numbers that go to a friend.

Red flags: paystub math doesn’t work (year-to-date doesn’t match pay period × periods); round numbers; no taxes withheld; employer only has a P.O. box or cell phone; W-2 wages don’t match IRS transcripts; the borrower’s stated job doesn’t fit their education or age; self-employed income that jumped suddenly.

Asset fraud

Faking or borrowing the money for the down payment and reserves: altered bank statements, undisclosed loans disguised as gifts, or temporarily “renting” someone else’s assets.

Red flags: large recent deposits with no source; balances that don’t match the transaction history; a gift letter from someone with no clear relationship or from an interested party (like the seller); funds that disappear right after closing.

Illegal property flipping

Buying a property cheap and reselling it quickly at an inflated price supported by a fraudulent appraisal, often to a straw buyer. (Legitimately fixing up and reselling a home isn’t fraud. The fraud is the inflated value and false documents.)

Red flags: a recent prior sale at a much lower price; little or no renovation to justify the jump; the seller has owned it only briefly; non-arm’s-length relationships among buyer, seller, and agent. (Recall the HPML rule requiring a second appraisal for certain quick resales.)

Other schemes to recognize

General red flags in the sales contract and application

The MLO’s responsibility

Criminal penalties

The URLA warns borrowers that false statements can be a federal crime. Knowingly making a false statement on a loan application to a federally insured institution is punishable by up to $1,000,000 in fines and 30 years in prison (18 U.S.C. §1014).

Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs)

Who must file

Since 2012, FinCEN’s rules under the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) treat non-bank residential mortgage lenders and originators (RMLOs) as “loan or finance companies.” They must:

(Banks and credit unions have their own SAR rules.)

When to file

A SAR is required for a transaction conducted by, at, or through the company that involves or adds up to at least $5,000 in funds or other assets, if the company knows, suspects, or has reason to suspect the transaction:

Deadlines and rules

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
SAR threshold for RMLOs $5,000 or more
SAR filing deadline 30 calendar days after initial detection
Extension if no suspect identified Another 30 days, maximum 60 days total
SAR record retention 5 years
False statement on a loan application (18 U.S.C. §1014) Up to $1,000,000 fine and 30 years in prison

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam