Learn / Ethics · Chapter 5 of 5

Ethical Behavior Day to Day: Consumers, Confidentiality, Complaints, and Tough Calls

How an ethical MLO handles borrower information, conflicts of interest, unlicensed assistants, elder financial abuse, complaints, and the everyday judgment calls the exam loves to test.

The short version

Relationships with consumers

Handling personal information and cybersecurity

Loan files are full of nonpublic personal information (NPI): SSNs, account numbers, income, and credit history. The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) sets the rules:

Everyday habits:

Outside parties seeking information

A real estate agent, the borrower’s relative, an ex-spouse, or a caller claiming to be “from the bank” asks about the borrower’s credit or income. Don’t share without the borrower’s authorization. It’s fine to tell the agent the loan’s status (like “clear to close”) if the borrower agreed, but not the borrower’s credit score or debts.

Requesting credit reports

Pull credit only with the borrower’s authorization and a permissible purpose under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Pulling a report “to see if they’re worth my time” without consent, or pulling a relative’s or friend’s report out of curiosity, is a violation.

Disclosing conflicts of interest

A conflict exists when the MLO’s interest could influence advice to the borrower:

The ethical response: disclose the conflict in writing (an AfBA disclosure where it applies), let the borrower choose freely, and follow state law. If the conflict can’t be managed, step aside.

Dual compensation

An MLO may not be paid by both the borrower and the lender on the same loan (Regulation Z). And an MLO shouldn’t take side payments from anyone else in the transaction. See the kickbacks chapter.

Changes in down payment or interest rate

If the down payment, rate, or other terms change, tell the borrower promptly, explain why, and re-disclose as required (a revised Loan Estimate or corrected Closing Disclosure). Hiding a change until the closing table is bait and switch.

Powers of attorney

Use a POA only with lender approval, confirm it’s valid and properly notarized, and watch for abuse, especially when an agent is signing for an elderly or ill borrower. An MLO should never act as attorney-in-fact on a loan they originate.

Non-resident co-borrowers

A relative who won’t live in the home (like a parent) may be added to help the borrower qualify, if the loan program allows it. The co-borrower must be real: they sign the note, are fully liable, and their information is verified. Adding someone who doesn’t know they’re on the loan, or who is paid to lend their credit, is a straw buyer scheme.

Unreported or fluctuating income

Gifts and unexplained deposits

Document every gift with a gift letter and proof of transfer. Ask about every large or unusual deposit. If the “gift” must be repaid, it’s a loan and must be disclosed.

Appraiser interactions

The MLO may give the appraiser the sales contract and property access information, ask them to consider additional comps, or correct factual errors. The MLO may not suggest a target value, pressure the appraiser, or threaten to stop sending work.

Multiple applications

Borrowers may apply with more than one lender to compare offers. That’s their right. But if the MLO learns of another pending loan or new debt, the underwriter must know, because it affects the DTI. Hiding simultaneous loans on different properties can be fraud.

Financial abuse of the elderly

Older adults are frequent targets of financial exploitation, sometimes by strangers, sometimes by family members or caregivers.

Warning signs:

What the MLO should do:

Handling borrower complaints

  1. Listen respectfully and let the borrower explain.
  2. Document the complaint: date, what happened, what the borrower wants.
  3. Follow company procedures: route to the manager or compliance department.
  4. Respond promptly and honestly; fix legitimate errors (for example, refund a tolerance violation).
  5. Never retaliate or discourage the borrower from contacting regulators.

Consumers can also complain to the CFPB (through its online complaint portal) and to state regulators. They can look up an MLO’s license status on NMLS Consumer Access.

Once a loan is being serviced, RESPA’s error-resolution rules apply: the servicer must acknowledge a borrower’s written notice of error within 5 business days and generally respond within 30 business days.

Unlicensed assistants

The SAFE Act requires anyone who takes a residential mortgage loan application or offers or negotiates loan terms for compensation to be licensed (or, for employees of banks and credit unions, registered) through NMLS.

Mortgage company compliance

General business ethics

Falsified information

Solicited and unsolicited advice

Scenario playbook: what should the MLO do?

Situation Best response
The borrower asks you to leave a car loan off the application “since it’s almost paid off” Refuse; all debts must be disclosed. Explain how it’s treated under program rules.
A real estate agent offers you $500 for each client you send them Decline; it’s a RESPA Section 8 kickback.
A large deposit appears in the borrower’s account the week before application Ask for a written explanation and documentation of the source.
The borrower’s daughter insists on handling everything for her 82-year-old father Speak with the father privately; confirm his understanding and wishes; escalate concerns.
The appraisal comes in low and the seller’s agent asks you to “call the appraiser and get it fixed” Don’t pressure the appraiser. You may submit additional comps or factual corrections through proper channels.
Your assistant (unlicensed) wants to quote rates to callers while you’re out Not allowed. They can take a message or schedule a callback.
The borrower tells you after approval that they’ll rent the house out instead of living in it Tell the underwriter; the loan must reflect investment occupancy.
You suspect the borrower’s paystubs are fake Don’t confront them about a possible SAR. Verify through independent sources and report to compliance.
A borrower complains about a fee that increased at closing Listen, document, check tolerances, route it to the proper department, and fix it if it was an error.
A caller says he’s the borrower’s husband and wants her credit score Don’t share without her authorization.

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
FTC Safeguards Rule breach notice threshold 500 or more consumers
FTC Safeguards Rule notice deadline Within 30 days of discovery
Servicer acknowledges notice of error Within 5 business days
Servicer responds to notice of error (generally) Within 30 business days

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam