Learn / Federal Mortgage Laws · Chapter 8 of 18

Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgages

The 8 ATR underwriting factors, what makes a loan a Qualified Mortgage, the 2026 points-and-fees caps, and the General QM price test.

The short version

Why the rule exists

Before 2008, many loans were made with little or no proof of income (“no-doc” loans) and payments the borrower could only afford for a short time. Dodd-Frank responded with the ATR requirement, which took effect in January 2014.

What loans are covered

ATR applies to closed-end consumer credit secured by a dwelling (including first and second liens, and loans on second homes).

Not covered:

The 8 ATR underwriting factors

A creditor must consider:

  1. Current or reasonably expected income or assets (other than the home itself)
  2. Current employment status (if relying on employment income)
  3. The monthly payment on the loan
  4. The monthly payment on any simultaneous loan (like a piggyback second mortgage) the creditor knows about
  5. Monthly mortgage-related obligations (property taxes, insurance, HOA dues, mortgage insurance)
  6. Current debt obligations, alimony, and child support
  7. Monthly debt-to-income (DTI) ratio or residual income
  8. Credit history

Verification

The creditor must verify the information it relies on using reasonably reliable third-party records, such as tax returns, W-2s, pay stubs, bank statements, and credit reports.

How to calculate the payment

For ATR, the creditor must use the greater of the fully indexed rate or any introductory rate, and monthly, fully amortizing, substantially equal payments. (A teaser rate can’t be used to make the loan look affordable.) Special rules apply to balloon, interest-only, and negative amortization loans.

Record retention

Keep evidence of ATR compliance for 3 years after consummation.

Qualified Mortgages (QMs)

A QM is presumed to comply with ATR, which protects the lender from borrower lawsuits. There are several types, but the exam focuses on the General QM.

Features a QM can NOT have

QM points-and-fees caps (2026)

These dollar amounts are adjusted every January for inflation. For loans consummated in 2026:

Loan amount Maximum points and fees
$137,958 or more 3% of the total loan amount
$82,775 to $137,957 $4,139
$27,592 to $82,774 5% of the total loan amount
$17,245 to $27,591 $1,380
Less than $17,245 8% of the total loan amount

“Points and fees” generally includes origination fees and points, loan originator compensation, and certain fees paid to affiliates. It generally excludes bona fide third-party charges not retained by the creditor or its affiliates and a limited amount of bona fide discount points.

General QM: the price-based test

Since October 1, 2022 (the mandatory compliance date), the General QM uses pricing instead of the old 43% DTI limit. The creditor must still consider and verify income, assets, debts, and DTI or residual income, but there is no specific DTI cap.

The loan’s APR can’t exceed the average prime offer rate (APOR) for a comparable loan (as of the date the rate is set) by these amounts or more (2026 figures, adjusted yearly):

Loan type and amount (2026) QM fails if APR exceeds APOR by
First lien, $137,958 or more 2.25 or more percentage points
First lien, $82,775 to $137,957 3.5 or more percentage points
First lien, less than $82,775 6.5 or more percentage points
First lien on a manufactured home, less than $137,958 6.5 or more percentage points
Subordinate lien, $82,775 or more 3.5 or more percentage points
Subordinate lien, less than $82,775 6.5 or more percentage points

The APOR is a benchmark rate the CFPB publishes weekly, based on rates offered to low-risk borrowers.

When figuring the APR for an adjustable-rate loan whose rate can change in the first 5 years, the creditor uses the maximum rate that can apply during the first 5 years.

Safe harbor vs. rebuttable presumption

QM type Level of protection
QM that is not “higher-priced” (first lien APR less than 1.5 points over APOR; subordinate lien less than 3.5) Safe harbor: conclusively presumed to comply
QM that is higher-priced Rebuttable presumption: borrower can try to prove the lender didn’t reasonably consider their ability to repay

Other QM types (know the names)

Prepayment penalties

A loan subject to ATR can have a prepayment penalty only if it’s a fixed-rate or step-rate QM that is not a higher-priced loan, and state law allows it. Even then:

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
ATR underwriting factors 8
ATR effective January 2014
Bridge/temporary loans exempt if term is 12 months or less
QM maximum term 30 years
QM points and fees, loans ≥ $137,958 (2026) 3%
QM points and fees, $82,775–$137,957 (2026) $4,139
QM points and fees, $27,592–$82,774 (2026) 5%
QM points and fees, $17,245–$27,591 (2026) $1,380
QM points and fees, below $17,245 (2026) 8%
General QM price limit, first lien ≥ $137,958 (2026) Less than 2.25 points over APOR
Safe harbor if first-lien APR is below APOR + 1.5 points
Safe harbor if subordinate-lien APR is below APOR + 3.5 points
ARM rate used for QM Max rate in first 5 years
Seasoned QM seasoning period 36 months
Prepayment penalty years 1–2 Max 2%
Prepayment penalty year 3 Max 1%
Prepayment penalty after year 3 Not allowed
Keep ATR records 3 years

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam