Learn / Federal Mortgage Laws · Chapter 7 of 18

TRID Tolerances and Changed Circumstances

Which closing costs can't go up at all, which can rise 10% in total, which can change freely, and when a revised Loan Estimate is allowed.

The short version

What “tolerance” means

The Loan Estimate is a good faith estimate. TRID measures good faith by comparing what the borrower actually pays at closing (on the Closing Disclosure) to what was on the Loan Estimate. How much a charge may go up depends on its tolerance category.

The three tolerance buckets

Zero tolerance (can’t increase at all)

10% cumulative tolerance

These are added up. The sum of all charges in this bucket can’t exceed the sum on the LE by more than 10%. One fee can go up a lot as long as the total stays within 10%.

Example: The LE shows recording fees of $100, title services (from the list) of $1,200, and a survey (from the list) of $300 = $1,600 total. 10% of $1,600 = $160, so the limit is $1,760. At closing these total $1,800. The overage is $1,800 − $1,760 = $40, which the creditor must refund.

Unlimited (no tolerance limit)

These can change by any amount, as long as the original estimate was made in good faith using the best information available:

Revised Loan Estimates: when costs can be reset

A creditor can use a revised estimate (resetting the baseline for tolerances) only for these reasons:

  1. Changed circumstance affecting settlement charges. A “changed circumstance” is:
    • an extraordinary event beyond anyone’s control (like a natural disaster), or another unexpected event specific to the borrower or transaction;
    • information the creditor relied on that turns out to be inaccurate or changes (for example, the appraisal comes in lower than the estimated value); or
    • new information specific to the borrower or transaction that the creditor didn’t rely on originally (for example, a newly discovered lien that requires extra title work).
  2. Changed circumstance affecting eligibility: the borrower’s creditworthiness or property value changes so they no longer qualify for the original terms.
  3. Borrower-requested changes (for example, the borrower asks for a different loan amount or loan program).
  4. Interest rate lock. If the rate wasn’t locked when the LE was issued, a revised LE is required within 3 business days after the rate is locked (showing the new rate, points, lender credits, and other rate-dependent charges).
  5. Expiration: the borrower indicated intent to proceed more than 10 business days after the LE was provided (or after any longer deadline the creditor set).
  6. Delayed settlement on new construction: if settlement is expected more than 60 days after the LE, and the LE clearly said revised disclosures may be issued, the creditor can revise it any time up to 60 days before consummation.

Timing rules for revised LEs

The revision only resets the charges affected by the changed circumstance. It isn’t a free pass to raise unrelated fees.

Curing a tolerance violation

If the borrower pays more than the tolerance allows, the creditor must refund the excess no later than 60 days after consummation and deliver or mail a corrected CD showing the refund within the same 60 days. Lenders often cure the problem at closing with a lender credit.

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
Zero-tolerance increase allowed 0%
Cumulative tolerance bucket 10% (total of the bucket)
Revised LE after changed circumstance Within 3 business days
Revised LE after rate lock Within 3 business days of lock
Revised LE must be received At least 4 business days before consummation
LE expiration for intent to proceed 10 business days
New construction revision allowed if settlement is More than 60 days after the LE
Refund of tolerance violation Within 60 days after consummation

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam