The short version
- An MLO’s pay can’t be based on the loan’s terms (like the interest rate, fees, or loan type) or a proxy for them. Pay based on a fixed percentage of the loan amount is allowed.
- No dual compensation: if the borrower pays the loan originator directly, no one else (like the lender) can pay the originator on that loan.
- No steering: an MLO can’t push a borrower into a loan because it pays the MLO more, unless it’s in the borrower’s interest. The safe harbor is presenting three options: lowest rate, lowest rate without risky features, and lowest total points and fees.
- The name and NMLS ID of the company and the individual MLO must appear on the application, Loan Estimate, Closing Disclosure, note, and security instrument.
Why these rules exist
Before 2011, many brokers were paid yield spread premiums: the higher the interest rate the borrower accepted, the more the broker earned. That gave originators a reason to put borrowers into costlier loans. Reg Z’s loan originator compensation rules (12 CFR 1026.36, strengthened by Dodd-Frank in 2014) removed that incentive.
The rules apply to closed-end consumer credit secured by a dwelling (and some parts apply to HELOCs).
Who is a “loan originator”?
Under Reg Z, a loan originator is anyone who, for compensation, takes an application, offers, arranges, negotiates, or helps a consumer obtain credit, or refers a consumer to a creditor or loan originator. It includes:
- Individual loan originators (the people, such as MLOs)
- Loan originator organizations (mortgage brokerage firms)
- Creditors that use table funding
Rule 1: No pay based on loan terms
No one may pay, and no loan originator may receive, compensation based on:
- a term of the transaction (interest rate, APR, points, fees, loan product, prepayment penalty, LTV, etc.), or
- a proxy for a term (a factor that consistently varies with a term and that the originator can change, such as whether the loan is sold to a particular investor, when that tracks the rate).
What IS allowed
- A fixed percentage of the loan amount (for example, 1% of the loan amount), which may have a minimum and maximum dollar amount. The amount of credit is not treated as a “term.”
- Salary and hourly wages.
- Pay based on loan volume (number of loans or total dollar volume) or quality measures, like performance of loans or customer satisfaction.
- Contributions to qualified retirement plans (such as a 401(k)), as long as they aren’t based on the terms of the individual’s loans.
- Non-deferred profits-based bonuses from the company’s mortgage business, if not tied to the individual’s loan terms and either (a) they total no more than 10% of the individual’s total compensation for the period, or (b) the individual originated 10 or fewer loans in the prior 12 months.
What’s NOT allowed
- Earning more for a higher interest rate or for adding a prepayment penalty.
- Lowering the MLO’s compensation to cover a pricing concession or an unexpected cost increase (with narrow exceptions for unforeseen increases in third-party closing costs).
- Pay that differs by loan product (for example, a bigger commission on ARMs than fixed-rate loans).
Rule 2: No dual compensation
If a loan originator receives compensation directly from the consumer, then:
- the loan originator can’t receive compensation from anyone else (like the lender) for that loan, and
- no one who knows about the consumer’s payment can pay the loan originator for that loan.
Also, if a mortgage broker company is paid directly by the consumer, it may still pay its own employees (individual MLOs), but the individual MLOs can’t be paid by the consumer or the creditor on that loan.
Borrower-paid vs. lender-paid: a broker’s compensation on a given loan must come from either the borrower or the lender, never both. Payments from a seller or other third party toward the borrower’s costs are treated as coming from the consumer.
Rule 3: No steering
A loan originator can’t direct or “steer” a consumer into a loan because it pays the originator more than other loans the originator offered or could have offered, unless the loan is in the consumer’s interest.
The anti-steering safe harbor
A loan originator is protected if, for each type of loan the consumer is interested in (fixed-rate, adjustable-rate, or reverse mortgage), it obtains options from a significant number of the creditors it regularly does business with and presents these options:
- The loan with the lowest interest rate
- The loan with the lowest interest rate without risky features: no negative amortization, prepayment penalty, interest-only payments, balloon payment in the first 7 years, demand feature, shared equity, or shared appreciation
- The loan with the lowest total dollar amount of discount points, origination points, or origination fees (if there’s a tie, the one with the lowest rate)
The originator must believe in good faith that the consumer likely qualifies for each option. If it presents more than three loans, it must highlight the ones that meet these criteria. It can present fewer than three if the loans presented meet all the criteria.
Rule 4: Qualification of loan originators
Loan originator organizations must make sure each individual MLO is licensed or registered under the SAFE Act before originating. For employees who don’t need a license (for example, employees of a bank who are registered instead), the organization must:
- get a criminal background check, a credit report, and NMLS information about administrative, civil, or criminal findings, and
- make sure the person meets character and fitness and criminal history standards, and
- provide periodic training on federal and state law for the loan products they originate.
Rule 5: NMLS ID on loan documents
For loans secured by a dwelling, these documents must show the name and NMLS ID of the loan originator organization and of the individual loan originator with primary responsibility:
- The credit application
- The Loan Estimate
- The Closing Disclosure
- The note or loan contract
- The security instrument (mortgage or deed of trust)
Other 1026.36 prohibitions
- No mandatory arbitration clauses in mortgage or HELOC contracts, and no provisions waiving federal claims.
- No financing of single-premium credit insurance (credit life, disability, unemployment) premiums into the loan (monthly-paid premiums are OK).
Record retention
Creditors and loan originator organizations must keep records of compensation paid or received, and the compensation agreements, for 3 years after the date of payment.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| Profits-based bonus limit | No more than 10% of total compensation (or originated 10 or fewer loans in 12 months) |
| Anti-steering options | 3 per loan type |
| Balloon feature excluded from “risky features” loan | Balloon in first 7 years |
| Loan types for steering safe harbor | Fixed-rate, adjustable-rate, reverse mortgage |
| Documents that need NMLS IDs | 5 (application, LE, CD, note, security instrument) |
| Keep compensation records | 3 years |
Memory tricks
- “Pay on the amount, not the terms.” A fixed percentage of the loan amount is fine. Anything tied to the rate is not.
- “One payer per loan.” Borrower or lender, never both.
- Steering safe harbor = “Low rate, Low risk, Low fees.”
- NMLS ID on “A-L-C-N-S”: Application, LE, CD, Note, Security instrument. Think: “All Loans Carry NMLS Stamps.”
Watch out on the exam
- Paying an MLO a higher commission for a higher rate is the classic violation. So is a bigger bonus for loans with prepayment penalties.
- Volume-based pay is allowed. “An MLO earns more for closing more loans” is not a violation.
- A fixed percentage of the loan amount is allowed even though bigger loans pay more, because the amount of credit is not a term of the transaction.
- Reducing an MLO’s pay to give the borrower a lower rate is generally not allowed. (The creditor can reduce its own profit instead.)
- Dual compensation trap: the borrower pays the broker a fee and the lender pays the broker a yield spread. Not allowed.
- The steering safe harbor requires presenting options for each type of transaction the borrower is interested in, not just one loan overall.