Learn / Federal Mortgage Laws · Chapter 11 of 18

ECOA and Regulation B: Fair Lending and Adverse Action

The prohibited bases for credit decisions, what you can and can't ask on an application, the 30-day notice rule, adverse action notices, and the appraisal copy rule.

The short version

Purpose and scope

ECOA (passed in 1974) makes credit available fairly and without discrimination to all creditworthy applicants. Unlike most consumer laws, ECOA covers all credit: consumer, business, and commercial, not just mortgages.

The prohibited bases

A creditor may not discriminate in any part of a credit transaction on the basis of:

  1. Race
  2. Color
  3. Religion
  4. National origin
  5. Sex
  6. Marital status
  7. Age (as long as the applicant is old enough to sign a binding contract)
  8. Receipt of income from any public assistance program (such as Social Security, SSI, or housing vouchers)
  9. Good-faith exercise of rights under the Consumer Credit Protection Act (such as disputing a credit report error or suing under TILA)

Discouraging applicants (saying or doing something that would discourage a reasonable person from applying) on a prohibited basis is also illegal.

Evaluating applications: permissible and forbidden acts

Age and public assistance

Income

A creditor may not discount or exclude income because it comes from:

The creditor can consider how much income there is and how likely it is to continue. It must treat all applicants’ income sources the same way.

Childbearing

A creditor can’t ask about birth control, plans to have children, or ability to have children, and can’t assume someone’s income will drop because they might have kids. It may ask about the number and ages of dependents and dependent-related expenses.

What you may and may not ask

Topic Rule
Marital status For a mortgage (or other secured or joint credit), you may ask, but only using “married,” “unmarried,” and “separated.” (“Unmarried” includes single, divorced, and widowed.)
Alimony / child support You may ask about it only after disclosing that the applicant doesn’t have to reveal it unless they want it considered. (You may ask whether the applicant is obligated to pay it.)
Spouse or former spouse Generally no, unless the spouse will use the account, will be liable, the applicant relies on the spouse’s income or alimony, or the applicant lives in a community property state.
Race, sex, national origin, religion No, except for government monitoring on mortgage applications (below).
Immigration status Permitted (a creditor can consider permanent residence).
Telephone listing Can’t consider whether there’s a phone listed in the applicant’s name.

Co-signers and spouse signatures

Creditworthiness: legitimate reasons to deny

A loan can be denied for legitimate, creditworthiness-based reasons applied consistently, such as insufficient income, too much debt (high DTI), poor credit history, insufficient collateral (low appraisal), unverifiable information, or insufficient length of employment.

Government monitoring information

On an application for a loan to buy or refinance the applicant’s principal residence, the creditor must ask for the applicant’s ethnicity, race, sex, marital status, and age. The applicant is asked but not required to answer.

If the applicant declines to provide this information:

The applicant must be told the information is collected by the federal government to monitor compliance with anti-discrimination laws and won’t be used in the credit decision.

Notifying the applicant: the 30-day rule

A creditor must notify the applicant of the action taken within:

Situation Deadline
Completed application (approval, counteroffer, or adverse action) 30 days after receiving it
Incomplete application 30 days after receiving it, either a notice of action taken or a notice of incompleteness
Adverse action on an existing account 30 days after taking it
Counteroffer not accepted or used by the applicant 90 days after the counteroffer notice

A notice of incompleteness must be written, say what information is needed, give a reasonable deadline, and state that the application won’t be considered further if the information isn’t provided.

Adverse action

Definition

Adverse action means:

It does not include actions related to default or delinquency, or changes the applicant agreed to.

What the notice must include

The notice must be in writing and include:

  1. A statement of the action taken
  2. The creditor’s name and address
  3. The ECOA notice (a statement that federal law prohibits discrimination on the prohibited bases)
  4. The name and address of the federal agency that oversees the creditor
  5. Either the specific reasons for the action, or a disclosure of the applicant’s right to get the reasons within 30 days if they ask within 60 days

Reasons must be specific (for example, “income insufficient for amount of credit requested”). Vague reasons like “didn’t meet our internal standards” aren’t enough.

If the decision was based on a credit report, the FCRA adds its own disclosures (chapter 12).

The appraisal copy rule (Reg B 1002.14)

For credit secured by a first lien on a dwelling:

Record retention

Keep applications and related records for 25 months after notifying the applicant of the action taken (12 months for most business credit).

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
Prohibited bases 9 (race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status, age, public assistance, exercising CCPA rights)
“Elderly” Age 62 or older
Notify of action on completed application 30 days
Notice on incomplete application 30 days
Counteroffer not accepted 90 days
Applicant may request reasons within 60 days of the notice
Creditor provides requested reasons within 30 days
Appraisal rights notice Within 3 business days of application
Appraisal copy Promptly on completion or 3 business days before closing, whichever is earlier
Appraisal timing waiver At least 3 business days before closing
Appraisal copy if loan doesn’t close Within 30 days
Record retention 25 months

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam