The short version
- The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) controls who can see a consumer report (credit report) and why. You need a permissible purpose, like a consumer’s credit application.
- FACTA (the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003) amended the FCRA to fight identity theft: free annual credit reports, fraud alerts, the credit score disclosure, risk-based pricing notices, and the Red Flags Rule.
- Mortgage lenders must give applicants a credit score disclosure (“Notice to Home Loan Applicant”). For mortgages, this also satisfies the risk-based pricing notice requirement if it includes the required extra information.
- The Red Flags Rule (16 CFR 681) requires a written Identity Theft Prevention Program that identifies, detects, and responds to red flags and is updated periodically.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
The FCRA (1970) promotes the accuracy, fairness, and privacy of information held by consumer reporting agencies (CRAs), like Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. The CFPB writes most FCRA rules (Regulation V, 12 CFR 1022); the FTC writes the Red Flags and Disposal Rules for non-banks.
Permissible purpose
A lender may pull a consumer’s credit report only with a permissible purpose, such as:
- a credit transaction the consumer initiated (a loan application),
- reviewing or collecting an existing account,
- the consumer’s written instructions, or
- employment purposes (with the consumer’s written permission).
Pulling a report without a permissible purpose, or under false pretenses, is illegal.
How long negative information stays on a report
- Most negative items (late payments, collections, charge-offs, foreclosures): 7 years
- Bankruptcies: up to 10 years
Consumer rights
- Get a copy of their file and dispute errors. The CRA generally must investigate within 30 days.
- Get a free report from each nationwide CRA once every 12 months (through the central source, AnnualCreditReport.com).
- Place a fraud alert or a free security freeze.
- Opt out of prescreened credit and insurance offers.
Duties of lenders (users of credit reports)
Adverse action based on a credit report
If a lender takes adverse action (denial, worse terms) based in whole or in part on a credit report, the FCRA requires telling the consumer:
- the name, address, and phone number of the CRA that supplied the report,
- that the CRA didn’t make the decision and can’t explain why it was made,
- the consumer’s right to a free copy of the report from that CRA if requested within 60 days,
- the right to dispute the accuracy of the report, and
- the credit score used and the key factors that hurt it.
Lenders usually combine this with the ECOA adverse action notice.
Credit score disclosure to home loan applicants
A lender that uses a credit score for a loan secured by 1–4 units of residential real property must give the applicant a “Notice to Home Loan Applicant” as soon as reasonably practicable. It includes:
- the applicant’s credit score and the range of possible scores,
- the key factors that hurt the score (up to 4, or 5 if the number of inquiries is a key factor),
- the date the score was created, and
- who provided the score (the CRA or scoring company).
Risk-based pricing notice
Risk-based pricing means giving worse terms (like a higher rate) to consumers with worse credit. If a lender uses a credit report to give a consumer materially less favorable terms than it gives most other consumers, it must send a risk-based pricing notice before closing.
Mortgage exception: For loans secured by 1–4 units of residential real property, the lender can instead give the credit score disclosure (above) plus extra information, such as a graph or statement showing how the score compares to other consumers, and a statement about free annual reports. This combined notice must be given at or before consummation. Most mortgage lenders give every applicant this “credit score exception notice.”
Furnishing information
Lenders that report to CRAs must report accurately, correct errors, and note when a consumer disputes an item.
Affiliate marketing opt-out
If a company wants to use information from an affiliate to market to a consumer, it must give the consumer a chance to opt out. The opt-out lasts at least 5 years.
Disposal Rule
Consumer report information must be disposed of securely (shredding, burning, or erasing electronic files so it can’t be read).
FACTA and identity theft
Fraud alerts
| Alert | How long | Who can request |
|---|---|---|
| Initial fraud alert | 1 year | Anyone who suspects they are or may be a victim of identity theft |
| Extended fraud alert | 7 years | Identity theft victims with an identity theft report |
| Active duty alert | 1 year | Military members on active duty |
When a fraud alert is on a report, a lender must take reasonable steps to verify the consumer’s identity before extending new credit (for an extended alert, contact the consumer by the phone number or method they listed).
Other FACTA protections
- Free annual credit reports
- Truncation of credit and debit card numbers on printed receipts
- Address discrepancy duties: when a CRA notifies a lender that the address the lender gave is substantially different from the one on file, the lender must have procedures to confirm the consumer’s identity.
The Red Flags Rule (16 CFR Part 681)
The Red Flags Rule applies to financial institutions and creditors (including mortgage lenders and brokers) that offer or maintain covered accounts, such as mortgage loans.
The Identity Theft Prevention Program
The company must have a written program, appropriate to its size and complexity, with reasonable policies and procedures to:
- Identify relevant red flags for its covered accounts,
- Detect those red flags,
- Respond appropriately to red flags that are detected, to prevent and reduce identity theft, and
- Update the program periodically to reflect new risks.
Administering the program
- The initial written program must be approved by the board of directors (or a board committee). If there’s no board, a senior management employee.
- The board, a committee, or senior management must oversee it, and staff must be trained.
- Service providers must be monitored.
Examples of red flags
- Documents that look altered or forged
- A photo or physical description on ID that doesn’t match the applicant
- A fraud alert on the credit report
- An SSN that hasn’t been issued, or belongs to a deceased person
- An address discrepancy notice from a CRA
- Information that is inconsistent with other information on the application (like an age that doesn’t match the SSN issue date)
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| Most negative info reported for | 7 years |
| Bankruptcy reported for | Up to 10 years |
| Free report from each nationwide CRA | Once every 12 months |
| CRA dispute investigation | Generally 30 days |
| Request free report after adverse action | Within 60 days |
| Key factors on credit score disclosure | Up to 4 (5 if inquiries are a factor) |
| Credit score disclosure applies to | 1–4 unit residential real property loans |
| Initial fraud alert | 1 year |
| Extended fraud alert | 7 years |
| Active duty alert | 1 year |
| Affiliate marketing opt-out | At least 5 years |
| FACTA enacted | 2003 |
| Red Flags program elements | 4 (identify, detect, respond, update) |
Memory tricks
- FCRA = “the Credit Report Act.” FACTA = “FCRA + Anti-Theft.”
- Red Flags = “I Detect Red Updates”: Identify, Detect, Respond, Update.
- Fraud alerts “1-7-1”: Initial 1 year, Extended 7 years, Active duty 1 year.
- “Seven for most, ten for bankrupt.”
Watch out on the exam
- The CRA doesn’t make lending decisions. The adverse action notice must say so.
- The credit score disclosure goes to all mortgage applicants whose score is used, not only denied ones.
- The Red Flags Rule is written by the FTC (for non-banks) and bank agencies; it’s a written program requirement, not just a checklist.
- The Red Flags program’s initial approval comes from the board of directors (or senior management if there’s no board), not the loan officer.
- Pulling a credit report “just to see” without a permissible purpose, like on a friend or an ex, is an FCRA violation.