The short version
- TRID (the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure rule) limits how much closing costs on the Closing Disclosure (CD) can rise above what was disclosed on the Loan Estimate (LE).
- Zero tolerance: fees can’t go up at all. Any increase must be refunded.
- 10% tolerance: add up all the fees in the bucket on the LE, multiply by 1.10, and compare to the total of the same fees on the CD. Cure = CD total − (LE total × 1.10), if positive.
- The lender must refund (cure) excess charges no later than 60 calendar days after consummation.
The three tolerance buckets
| Bucket | What’s in it | Can it increase? |
|---|---|---|
| Zero tolerance | Fees paid to the lender, mortgage broker, or their affiliates; fees for services the borrower was not allowed to shop for (for example, the appraisal and credit report); transfer taxes | No. Any increase is refunded. |
| 10% cumulative tolerance | Recording fees, and third-party services the borrower could shop for but chose from the lender’s written list of providers (and that aren’t the lender’s affiliates) | Yes, but the total can’t rise more than 10%. |
| No limit (unlimited) | Prepaid interest, homeowners insurance premiums, escrow deposits, services the borrower shopped for on their own (off the list), and third-party services the lender doesn’t require | Yes, as long as the LE was based on the best information available. |
Zero-tolerance cure
Cure = CD fee − LE fee (for each zero-tolerance fee that went up)
Worked example: zero tolerance
The LE showed a $1,500 origination fee and a $500 appraisal fee. The CD shows $1,650 and $550.
- Origination increase = $1,650 − $1,500 = $150
- Appraisal increase = $550 − $500 = $50
- Zero-tolerance cure = $150 + $50 = $200
10% tolerance cure
The 10% test is cumulative: compare the total of the bucket, not each fee one by one.
Step 1: LE total = sum of all 10%-bucket fees on the Loan Estimate
Step 2: Limit = LE total × 1.10
Step 3: CD total = sum of the same bucket’s fees on the Closing Disclosure
Step 4: Cure = CD total − Limit (if the answer is zero or negative, no cure is owed)
Worked example 1: cure owed
Loan Estimate: recording fees $150, lender’s title insurance $900, settlement fee $500, survey $350 (the title company, settlement agent, and surveyor were all chosen from the lender’s list). Closing Disclosure: recording fees $175, lender’s title insurance $1,050, settlement fee $600, survey $400.
- LE total = $150 + $900 + $500 + $350 = $1,900
- Limit = $1,900 × 1.10 = $2,090
- CD total = $175 + $1,050 + $600 + $400 = $2,225
- Cure = $2,225 − $2,090 = $135
The trap answer is $325 (the full increase from $1,900 to $2,225). The borrower is only owed the amount above the 10% allowance.
Worked example 2: one fee doubled, but no cure
LE: recording fees $100, title insurance $1,000. CD: recording fees $200, title insurance $950.
- LE total = $100 + $1,000 = $1,100
- Limit = $1,100 × 1.10 = $1,210
- CD total = $200 + $950 = $1,150
- $1,150 is less than $1,210 → no cure owed
Even though the recording fee doubled, the bucket as a whole stayed within 10%.
Worked example 3: total cure from both buckets
Using the two examples above (worked example 1 in this section and the zero-tolerance example):
- Total cure = $135 + $200 = $335
Resetting the baseline
A lender can issue a revised Loan Estimate (which resets the numbers used for the tolerance test) only for specific reasons, such as a valid changed circumstance or a borrower-requested change. The revised LE generally must be delivered within 3 business days after the lender learns of the change.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number or rule |
|---|---|
| Zero-tolerance increase allowed | $0 |
| 10% bucket limit | LE bucket total × 1.10 |
| 10% bucket cure | CD total − (LE total × 1.10) |
| Deadline to refund a tolerance violation | Within 60 calendar days after consummation |
| Revised LE after a changed circumstance | Within 3 business days |
Memory tricks
- “Zero for the lender’s own stuff.” Fees going to the lender, broker, or affiliates, or for services the borrower couldn’t shop for, can’t rise.
- “10% for the list and the recorder.” Services picked from the lender’s list, plus recording fees.
- “Sum, times 1.1, subtract.” Three moves for the 10% cure.
- “Shopped on your own, you’re on your own.” Services the borrower found independently have no limit.
Watch out on the exam
- Fee-by-fee testing in the 10% bucket. It’s the total that matters.
- Refunding the whole increase. Only the amount above 110% is refunded in the 10% bucket. (In the zero bucket, the whole increase is refunded.)
- Multiplying the CD total by 1.10. The 110% limit is based on the Loan Estimate.
- Putting a borrower-shopped provider in the 10% bucket. If the borrower picked a provider not on the lender’s list, that fee has no tolerance limit.
- Transfer taxes. They’re zero tolerance, even though they’re paid to the government. Recording fees are 10%.