Learn / Mortgage Math · Chapter 11 of 14

APR: Why It's Higher Than the Note Rate

What the Annual Percentage Rate measures, why it's usually above the note rate, the APR tolerance rules, and simple APR threshold comparisons.

The short version

Note rate vs. APR

The note rate is written in the promissory note and determines the monthly principal-and-interest payment.

The APR, required by the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and its rule, Regulation Z, expresses the total cost of credit as a yearly rate so consumers can compare loans that have different rates and fees.

What’s in the APR (finance charges)

Typical finance charges include:

What’s usually left out (in a real estate loan)

Why APR is higher: a simple example

The math that produces an exact APR requires a financial calculator, and the exam won’t ask you to do it. But you should understand the idea.

Amount financed = Loan amount − Prepaid finance charges

Worked example: the concept

A borrower takes a $200,000, 30-year loan at a 6% note rate. The monthly P&I is $1,199.10. At closing, the borrower pays $4,000 in points and lender fees (prepaid finance charges).

  1. Amount financed = $200,000 − $4,000 = $196,000
  2. The borrower still makes 360 payments of $1,199.10, which pay back $200,000 plus interest.
  3. Repaying $200,000 of payments for only $196,000 of real money is like paying a higher rate.
  4. Solving for that rate (with a financial calculator) gives an APR of about 6.19%, higher than the 6.00% note rate.

When APR equals (or is below) the note rate

APR tolerance

Under Regulation Z, a disclosed APR is considered accurate if it’s within:

After the Closing Disclosure is given, if the APR increases beyond that tolerance, the lender must provide a corrected Closing Disclosure, and the borrower gets a new 3-business-day waiting period before closing.

Worked example: is it within tolerance?

The Closing Disclosure showed an APR of 6.250% on a regular fixed-rate loan. Just before closing, the APR rises to 6.400%.

  1. Change = 6.400% − 6.250% = 0.150%
  2. Tolerance for a regular transaction = 0.125%
  3. 0.150% is more than 0.125% → outside tolerance: a new 3-business-day waiting period is required

APR threshold tests (HPML and HOEPA)

Regulators compare a loan’s APR to the APOR (Average Prime Offer Rate), a benchmark rate published weekly that reflects rates offered to prime borrowers.

Test First-lien trigger Notes
Higher-priced mortgage loan (HPML) APR ≥ APOR + 1.5 percentage points + 2.5 for first-lien jumbo loans; + 3.5 for subordinate liens
High-cost mortgage (HOEPA) APR > APOR + 6.5 percentage points + 8.5 for subordinate liens (and small first liens on personal property)

HOEPA also has a separate points-and-fees test whose dollar thresholds are adjusted every year.

Worked example: HPML test

A first-lien, non-jumbo loan has an APR of 7.95%. The APOR for a comparable loan is 6.40%.

  1. HPML trigger = 6.40% + 1.5% = 7.90%
  2. Is 7.95% ≥ 7.90%? Yes → the loan is a higher-priced mortgage loan

Numbers to memorize

Item Number or rule
Amount financed Loan − prepaid finance charges
APR tolerance, regular transaction 1/8 of 1% (0.125%)
APR tolerance, irregular transaction 1/4 of 1% (0.25%)
New waiting period if APR becomes inaccurate after the CD 3 business days
HPML trigger (first lien) APOR + 1.5
HPML trigger (first-lien jumbo) APOR + 2.5
HPML trigger (subordinate lien) APOR + 3.5
HOEPA APR trigger (first lien) APOR + 6.5
HOEPA APR trigger (subordinate lien) APOR + 8.5

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam