The short version
- Zero tolerance: fees paid to the lender, the broker, or their affiliates, fees for services the borrower can’t shop for, and transfer taxes. These can’t increase at all (without a valid reason).
- 10% cumulative tolerance: recording fees and third-party services the borrower could shop for but picked from the lender’s list. Added together, they can’t rise more than 10%.
- No tolerance (can change freely): prepaid interest, homeowner’s insurance premiums, escrow deposits, services the borrower shopped for on their own, and services the lender doesn’t require.
- If the lender blows a tolerance, it must refund the excess within 60 calendar days after consummation.
What “good faith” means on a Loan Estimate
The lender must disclose charges in good faith. The regulation measures good faith by comparing the fees on the Loan Estimate with what the borrower actually pays at closing (on the Closing Disclosure). How much a fee may grow depends on its tolerance bucket.
The three tolerance buckets
Zero tolerance (0%)
These may not increase at all compared with the Loan Estimate:
- Fees paid to the creditor (origination charges, discount points, underwriting fees)
- Fees paid to a mortgage broker
- Fees paid to an affiliate of the creditor or broker
- Fees for third-party services the borrower is not allowed to shop for (for example, the appraisal and credit report, when the lender picks the provider)
- Transfer taxes
10% cumulative tolerance
These may increase, but the sum of all of them can’t be more than 10% above the sum on the Loan Estimate:
- Recording fees
- Third-party services the borrower is allowed to shop for and chooses from the lender’s written list of providers, as long as the provider isn’t an affiliate of the lender
The test is on the total, not each fee. One fee can go up 30% if others went down enough to keep the total within 10%.
No limit (“unlimited” tolerance)
These can change without a tolerance violation, as long as the original estimate was made in good faith using the best information available:
- Prepaid interest (per-diem interest)
- Property insurance premiums (homeowner’s insurance)
- Amounts placed into escrow (initial deposit for taxes and insurance)
- Services the borrower shopped for on their own (a provider not on the lender’s list)
- Services not required by the lender (for example, an owner’s title policy or a home inspection the borrower wanted)
Violation scenarios
| Scenario | Violation? |
|---|---|
| LE origination fee $1,000; CD shows $1,100, no changed circumstance | Yes (zero tolerance). Refund $100. |
| LE appraisal $500 (lender chose appraiser); CD $550 | Yes (can’t shop = zero tolerance). Refund $50. |
| Lender-list title fees + recording on LE total $2,000; CD total $2,150 | No (7.5%, within 10%) |
| Same, CD total $2,300 | Yes. Allowed max is $2,200; refund $100 |
| Borrower picked own title company (not on list); fees rose $400 | No (no tolerance) |
| Homeowner’s insurance premium was $200 higher than estimated | No (no tolerance) |
Curing a tolerance violation
If amounts paid exceed the allowed tolerance, the creditor must refund the excess no later than 60 calendar days after consummation and give a corrected Closing Disclosure. Often the fix happens at closing as a lender credit shown on the CD.
When can the lender issue a revised Loan Estimate?
A revised LE “resets” the baseline for tolerance purposes, but only when a valid reason exists. The valid reasons (“triggering events”) are:
- Changed circumstance affecting settlement charges: an extraordinary event beyond anyone’s control (like a natural disaster), information the creditor relied on that turns out to be inaccurate or changes, or new information specific to the borrower or transaction the creditor didn’t have when it issued the LE.
- Changed circumstance affecting eligibility: new information shows the borrower no longer qualifies for the terms disclosed (for example, the income can’t be verified at the amount stated).
- Revisions requested by the consumer (a different loan amount, a different program, a lower rate with more points).
- Interest rate lock: if the rate wasn’t locked when the LE was issued, the creditor must send a revised LE within 3 business days after the rate is locked, showing the locked rate, points, lender credits, and other rate-dependent charges.
- Expiration: the borrower didn’t indicate intent to proceed within 10 business days after the LE was provided.
- Delayed settlement on construction loans: for new construction where settlement is expected more than 60 days after the initial LE, if the creditor clearly said so on the LE.
A change only lets the lender raise the charges affected by that change. For example, a low appraisal that pushes the loan-to-value ratio higher could justify higher mortgage insurance but not a higher underwriting fee.
Timing of a revised LE
- Must be delivered within 3 business days after the creditor gets information sufficient to establish the valid reason.
- Must be received no later than 4 business days before consummation.
- A revised LE may not be given on or after the day the Closing Disclosure is given. After that, changes go on a corrected CD.
Rate locks
A rate lock is the lender’s promise to hold a specific interest rate and points for a set period (commonly 30, 45, or 60 days) while the loan is processed.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Lock | The rate and points are fixed for the lock period, even if market rates move. |
| Float | The borrower hasn’t locked yet. The rate moves with the market until they lock. |
| Float-down | An optional feature (often for a fee) letting a locked borrower get a lower rate if the market drops. |
| Lock extension | If closing is delayed past the lock expiration, the borrower may pay a fee to extend. If the lock expires, the loan is repriced at current market rates. |
| Lock confirmation | Written confirmation of the locked terms. |
Key compliance points:
- The Loan Estimate shows whether the rate is locked and, if so, when the lock expires.
- Locking an unlocked rate after the LE triggers a revised LE within 3 business days.
- A lock fee can’t be charged before the borrower receives the LE and indicates intent to proceed.
- An MLO should explain the risk of floating honestly and must not tell the borrower a rate is locked when it isn’t.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| Zero-tolerance fees may increase by | 0% |
| Recording fees + shoppable services from lender’s list may increase by (in total) | 10% |
| Refund of tolerance violation | Within 60 calendar days after consummation |
| Revised LE after a triggering event or rate lock | Within 3 business days |
| Revised LE received before consummation | At least 4 business days |
| Intent to proceed before LE may be re-issued for any reason | 10 business days |
| Construction loan delayed settlement | More than 60 days after the initial LE |
Memory tricks
- Zero tolerance = “Lender, Locked-in, and Levies.” The lender’s own fees (and its broker and affiliates), services the borrower is locked in to (can’t shop), and levies (transfer taxes).
- 10% = “Recorded from the List.” Recording fees + providers picked from the lender’s list.
- Unlimited = “PIE and the Shopper.” Prepaid interest, Insurance, Escrow, plus anything the borrower shopped for on their own.
- Revised LE timing: “3 to send, 4 before the end.”
Watch out on the exam
- “Services the borrower can shop for” doesn’t automatically mean 10%. If the borrower chose a provider on the lender’s list, it’s 10%. If they went off-list, it’s unlimited. If the provider is the lender’s affiliate, it’s zero tolerance.
- The 10% is an aggregate. Don’t flag a single fee that went up 15% if the bucket total is within 10%.
- Transfer taxes are zero tolerance. Recording fees are 10%. Test writers love swapping them.
- A revised LE can’t follow the CD. After the CD is issued, any changes go on a corrected CD.
- A changed circumstance doesn’t unlock every fee, only the fees affected by the change.
- Rate locks don’t happen automatically when the LE is issued. Floating is the default until the borrower locks.