The short version
- Underwriters judge a loan by the 4 Cs: Capacity (can they pay?), Capital (what money do they have?), Credit (how have they paid before?), and Collateral (is the property worth enough?).
- Income must be stable, verified, and likely to continue. Employment is typically documented for the past 2 years. Self-employed borrowers usually provide 2 years of tax returns.
- Assets must be verified and sourced. Large, unexplained deposits and undocumented gifts are red flags.
- The ability-to-repay (ATR) rule requires the lender to make a reasonable, good-faith determination, using 8 factors, that the borrower can repay.
Processing vs. underwriting
- Processing is getting the file ready: ordering the credit report, appraisal, title, verifications, and collecting documents.
- Underwriting is the decision: an underwriter (or an automated underwriting system such as Fannie Mae’s Desktop Underwriter, or DU, or Freddie Mac’s Loan Product Advisor, or LPA) reviews the risk and approves, approves with conditions, suspends, or denies.
The 4 Cs of credit
| C | Question | What the underwriter looks at |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | Can the borrower afford the payment? | Income, employment, debt-to-income ratio |
| Capital | Does the borrower have money in the deal and a cushion? | Down payment, closing funds, reserves |
| Credit | Has the borrower paid debts as agreed? | Credit report, credit score, payment history |
| Collateral | Is the property worth enough to secure the loan? | Appraisal, property type and condition, loan-to-value ratio |
Some texts add a 5th C, Character (reliability), but the exam usually focuses on the four above.
Income and employment
The basic standard
The lender must document that income is stable, has a history of receipt, and is reasonably expected to continue. If income has a known end date (like alimony, some trust income, or support that ends when a child turns 18), Fannie Mae requires that it be expected to continue for at least 3 years from the note date to count.
Salaried and hourly (W-2) borrowers
Typical Fannie Mae documentation:
- Recent paystub dated no earlier than 30 days before the initial application, showing year-to-date earnings
- W-2 forms for the most recent 1 or 2 years (depending on the income type)
- A verbal verification of employment (VOE) within 10 business days before the note date, using a phone number the lender finds independently (not the number the borrower wrote down)
The URLA asks for a 2-year employment history. Gaps, frequent job changes, or a new line of work don’t automatically disqualify a borrower, but the underwriter wants an explanation.
Overtime, bonus, and commission income is variable. Lenders usually average it over a history (commonly two years) and look at the trend. If it’s declining, they may use the lower, current figure or not count it at all.
Self-employed borrowers
- Fannie Mae treats anyone with 25% or more ownership in a business as self-employed.
- Usually requires 2 years of self-employment history and 2 years of signed personal (and business, if applicable) federal tax returns, or IRS transcripts.
- A shorter history (at least 12 months on the tax returns) can work if the borrower previously earned similar income in the same field.
- Underwriters use net income after business expenses (what’s on the tax return), not gross receipts.
- Verification of the business’s existence must be done within 120 calendar days before the note date.
Income that can’t be used
- Unreported cash income that doesn’t show up on tax returns can’t be used to qualify.
- Income that won’t continue (a job ending next month, a temporary disability payment about to stop)
- Income the borrower can’t document
Verifying income
- Form 4506-C: the borrower authorizes the lender to get IRS tax transcripts to confirm income
- Verification of Employment (VOE): written or verbal, direct from the employer
- If an employer gives information that conflicts with the application (a different salary or job title), the MLO must not ignore it. The underwriter must resolve the conflict.
Assets and reserves
Why assets matter
The borrower needs verified funds for the down payment, closing costs, and sometimes reserves. Reserves are money left over after closing, usually measured in months of the full housing payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance, and association dues, or PITIA).
Bank statements
For manually underwritten Fannie Mae loans:
- Purchase: statements covering the most recent 2 full months (60 days)
- Refinance: the most recent 1 full month (30 days)
(Automated underwriting may require less; follow its findings.)
Large deposits
Fannie Mae defines a large deposit as a single deposit exceeding 50% of the total monthly qualifying income. On a purchase, if those funds are needed for the down payment, closing costs, or reserves, the lender must document where the money came from. On a refinance, documentation of large deposits isn’t required, though the lender must still make sure no borrowed money is hiding in the account.
Deposits that are obviously identifiable (payroll direct deposits, tax refunds, transfers between the borrower’s verified accounts) don’t need extra documentation.
Retirement and investment accounts
- Vested money in retirement accounts such as 401(k)s and IRAs can be used for down payment, closing costs, and reserves. The lender verifies ownership and vesting.
- When used as reserves, Fannie Mae doesn’t require the borrower to withdraw the money.
- Stocks and bonds can count; if used for the down payment or closing costs, the lender documents that they were actually sold and the cash received.
Borrowed funds
Unsecured borrowed money (a cash advance, an unsecured personal loan) generally can’t be used for the down payment, and any new debt must be counted in the DTI ratio. Loans secured by the borrower’s own assets (like a 401(k) loan) can be acceptable.
Gift funds
Under Fannie Mae’s rules:
- Acceptable donors: a relative (by blood, marriage, adoption, or legal guardianship), fiancé or fiancée, domestic partner, or someone with a close familial relationship
- Not acceptable: anyone with an interest in the transaction, such as the builder, developer, seller, or real estate agent
- Gift letter signed by the donor, stating the dollar amount, the donor’s name, address, phone number, and relationship, and that no repayment is expected
- Evidence of transfer: the donor’s check and borrower’s deposit slip, a wire or electronic transfer record, or proof the funds went directly to the closing agent
Minimum borrower contribution: For a one-unit principal residence, Fannie Mae requires no minimum contribution from the borrower’s own funds; a gift can cover it all. For 2–4 unit principal residences and second homes with LTV above 80%, the borrower must put in 5% of their own funds.
A “gift” that must be paid back is a loan, and calling it a gift is fraud.
Liabilities
Every monthly debt obligation goes into the DTI: car loans, student loans, credit card minimums, installment loans, alimony and child support payments, and other mortgages. Debts the borrower “forgot” but that show on the credit report must be addressed. New credit opened during the loan process can change the approval.
Credit reports and scores
- The lender must have the borrower’s authorization and a permissible purpose under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) to pull credit.
- Mortgage lenders use a merged credit report that combines data from the national credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion). A “tri-merge” pulls all three.
- Fannie Mae requires at least two scores per borrower. The borrower’s score is the middle of three scores, or the lower of two.
- The underwriter looks at payment history, amounts owed, length of history, recent inquiries, and public records such as bankruptcies and foreclosures.
- If the borrower applies with several lenders (multiple applications), recent inquiries show on the report. That’s normal rate shopping, but the underwriter may ask whether any new debt resulted.
Qualifying ratios (the concepts)
The math section shows how to compute these. Here’s what they mean:
| Ratio | Formula (concept) | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| Housing ratio (front-end) | Housing payment ÷ gross monthly income | Can they afford the house payment itself? |
| Debt-to-income (DTI) (back-end) | All monthly debts including housing ÷ gross monthly income | Can they afford all their debts? |
| Loan-to-value (LTV) | Loan amount ÷ lesser of sales price or appraised value | How much equity cushion protects the lender? |
| Combined LTV (CLTV) | All liens ÷ property value | LTV including second mortgages |
Limits depend on the loan program. For example, Fannie Mae’s maximum DTI is generally 36% for manually underwritten loans (up to 45% with strong credit and reserves), and up to 50% for loans run through DU.
The ability-to-repay (ATR) rule
Regulation Z requires the creditor to make a reasonable, good-faith determination that the borrower can repay a closed-end residential mortgage. It must consider and verify these 8 factors:
- Current or reasonably expected income or assets (other than the home itself)
- Current employment status (if relying on employment income)
- The monthly payment on this loan
- The monthly payment on any simultaneous loan (like a piggyback second)
- Monthly payments for mortgage-related obligations (property taxes, insurance, HOA dues)
- Current debt obligations, alimony, and child support
- The monthly debt-to-income ratio or residual income
- Credit history
A qualified mortgage (QM) gets legal protection (a presumption of compliance with ATR). QMs are covered in the General Mortgage Knowledge section.
Suitability
The MLO should recommend a loan that fits the borrower’s needs and ability to pay, not just the one that pays the MLO the most. Rules against steering (see the ethics section) back this up.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| Employment history on the URLA | 2 years |
| Self-employed: ownership share | 25% or more |
| Self-employed: typical tax returns | 2 years (12 months minimum in some cases) |
| Income with an end date must continue at least | 3 years |
| Paystub dated no earlier than | 30 days before application |
| Verbal VOE (salaried) | Within 10 business days before the note date |
| Self-employed business verification | Within 120 calendar days before the note date |
| Bank statements, purchase / refinance (Fannie manual) | 2 months / 1 month |
| Large deposit (Fannie Mae) | Single deposit over 50% of monthly qualifying income |
| Borrower minimum contribution with gift (2–4 units or second home, LTV > 80%) | 5% |
| Representative credit score | Middle of 3, lower of 2 |
| Fannie Mae max DTI: manual / manual with compensating factors / DU | 36% / 45% / 50% |
| ATR factors | 8 |
Memory tricks
- The 4 Cs as a story: “Can you pay (Capacity)? What have you saved (Capital)? Have you paid before (Credit)? What if you don’t (Collateral)?”
- Gift letter = “No payback, name, number, relationship, amount.”
- Large deposit = “More than half a month’s pay.”
- ATR factors: “I Earn My Payment, Simply, Mortgage Dues, Debts, Ratio, Credit” (Income, Employment, My Payment, Simultaneous loan, Mortgage-related, Debts, Ratio, Credit).
Watch out on the exam
- LTV uses the LOWER of price or appraised value. If the house appraises above the price, you still use the price.
- A gift from the seller or real estate agent is NOT a gift. It’s an interested-party contribution with separate rules.
- Verbal VOE phone number must be found independently, not taken from the borrower’s application.
- Unreported cash income can’t be used, no matter how the borrower explains it.
- Fluctuating income: if it’s declining, expect the underwriter to use the lower number.
- Large deposits on a refinance don’t need to be sourced under Fannie Mae’s rules (but the purchase rule is the one tested most).
- Capacity vs. capital: capacity is income and debt; capital is cash and assets.