Learn / Loan Origination Activities · Chapter 5 of 8

Appraisals: Valuing the Collateral

What an appraisal is for, the three approaches to value, appraiser independence rules, appraisal review, and when the borrower gets a copy.

The short version

Key definitions

Term Meaning
Appraisal A written estimate of value, prepared by a state-licensed or certified appraiser following the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)
Market value The most probable price a property would bring in a competitive, open market, with a typically motivated buyer and seller, both well informed and acting in their own interest, and no undue pressure
Subject property The property being appraised
Comparables (“comps”) Similar, recently sold nearby properties used to estimate the subject’s value
Adjustments Dollar changes to a comp’s price to account for differences from the subject
Reconciliation The appraiser’s final step: weighing the results of the approaches used to reach one final value
Highest and best use The legally allowed, physically possible, financially feasible use that produces the highest value
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (URAR) The standard single-family appraisal report form used by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (Fannie Mae Form 1004)

Purpose and timing

The three approaches to value

1. Sales comparison approach (market data approach)

Example: The subject has no garage. A comp with a garage sold for $300,000, and a garage is worth $15,000 in this market. Adjusted comp price: $300,000 − $15,000 = $285,000.

2. Cost approach

3. Income approach

Appraiser independence (Regulation Z §1026.42)

The Dodd-Frank Act added appraiser independence rules to TILA for consumer credit secured by the consumer’s principal dwelling.

Prohibited

Permitted

Other requirements

Getting a copy of the appraisal

Appraisal review

Lenders may check an appraisal’s quality before relying on it:

Red flags in an appraisal: comps far from the subject or much older than typical, large or inconsistent adjustments, a value exactly equal to the sales price with little support, photos that don’t match the address, and recent sales of the same property at much lower prices. See the fraud chapter.

Numbers to memorize

Item Number
ECOA right-to-copy notice Within 3 business days of application
Copy of appraisal Promptly on completion or 3 business days before consummation, whichever is earlier
HPML flip rule: second appraisal Resold within 90 days at more than 10% increase, or 91–180 days at more than 20% increase

Memory tricks

Watch out on the exam