The short version
- An appraisal is an independent, professional opinion of a property’s market value. It protects the lender by confirming the collateral is worth enough.
- The three approaches are sales comparison (compare recent sales, the main approach for homes), cost (land + cost to rebuild − depreciation), and income (value based on rent the property produces).
- Appraiser independence (Regulation Z §1026.42): nobody, including the MLO, may pressure, bribe, or coach an appraiser to hit a number.
- For first-lien dwelling loans, the borrower gets a free copy of every appraisal promptly on completion or 3 business days before consummation, whichever is earlier.
Key definitions
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Appraisal | A written estimate of value, prepared by a state-licensed or certified appraiser following the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) |
| Market value | The most probable price a property would bring in a competitive, open market, with a typically motivated buyer and seller, both well informed and acting in their own interest, and no undue pressure |
| Subject property | The property being appraised |
| Comparables (“comps”) | Similar, recently sold nearby properties used to estimate the subject’s value |
| Adjustments | Dollar changes to a comp’s price to account for differences from the subject |
| Reconciliation | The appraiser’s final step: weighing the results of the approaches used to reach one final value |
| Highest and best use | The legally allowed, physically possible, financially feasible use that produces the highest value |
| Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (URAR) | The standard single-family appraisal report form used by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (Fannie Mae Form 1004) |
Purpose and timing
- The appraisal shows whether the collateral (one of the 4 Cs) supports the loan. The LTV is based on the lower of the appraised value and the sales price.
- It’s usually ordered after the borrower receives the Loan Estimate and indicates intent to proceed, because the appraisal fee can’t be collected before then.
- A low appraisal can mean a bigger down payment, a renegotiated price, a different loan, or a denial. It can also be a valid changed circumstance for a revised Loan Estimate if it affects the loan terms.
The three approaches to value
1. Sales comparison approach (market data approach)
- Best for: owner-occupied single-family homes and condos. It’s the primary approach for most residential appraisals.
- How: Find recent sales of similar homes nearby. Adjust each comp’s sale price for differences from the subject.
- Adjustment rule: Always adjust the comp, never the subject.
- If the comp is better than the subject (has a feature the subject lacks), subtract value from the comp.
- If the comp is worse than the subject, add value to the comp.
Example: The subject has no garage. A comp with a garage sold for $300,000, and a garage is worth $15,000 in this market. Adjusted comp price: $300,000 − $15,000 = $285,000.
2. Cost approach
- Best for: new construction and unique or special-purpose properties with few comparable sales (churches, schools, fire stations). Also used to estimate insurable value.
- Formula: Land value + cost to build the improvements new − depreciation = value.
- Replacement cost: cost to build something with the same usefulness using modern materials.
- Reproduction cost: cost to build an exact replica.
- Three types of depreciation:
- Physical deterioration: wear and tear (an old roof)
- Functional obsolescence: outdated design (one bathroom in a five-bedroom house)
- External (economic) obsolescence: something outside the property lowers its value (a new highway next door). It’s the only kind that’s always incurable by the owner.
3. Income approach
- Best for: income-producing properties (rentals, apartment buildings, commercial property).
- How: Value is based on the income the property generates.
- Capitalization: Value = Net operating income (NOI) ÷ capitalization rate.
- Example: NOI of $30,000 ÷ 6% (0.06) = $500,000
- Gross rent multiplier (GRM): For small residential rentals, value = monthly gross rent × GRM.
Appraiser independence (Regulation Z §1026.42)
The Dodd-Frank Act added appraiser independence rules to TILA for consumer credit secured by the consumer’s principal dwelling.
Prohibited
- Coercing, bribing, extorting, or pressuring an appraiser (or colluding with one) to make the value hit a target, such as “We need it to come in at $400,000.”
- Withholding or threatening to withhold payment or future business because of the value reported
- Promising future work in exchange for a certain value
- Conflicts of interest: an appraiser can’t have a direct or indirect financial or other interest in the property or the transaction
- Misrepresenting the property’s value to a consumer
- Extending credit when the creditor knows of a violation, unless it uses reasonable diligence to confirm the value isn’t materially wrong
Permitted
- Asking the appraiser to consider additional information (for example, more comps)
- Asking the appraiser to provide more detail or explanation for the value
- Asking the appraiser to correct factual errors (wrong square footage)
- Getting multiple valuations to pick the most reliable one (not the highest)
- Withholding payment for breach of contract or substandard work
Other requirements
- Reporting: A creditor or settlement service provider that reasonably believes an appraiser has materially violated USPAP or ethics rules must report it to the state appraiser certifying and licensing agency.
- Customary and reasonable fees: Appraisers (including those hired through an appraisal management company, or AMC) must be paid a customary and reasonable fee for the market.
- Firewall: In practice, lenders keep the loan production staff (including MLOs, whose pay depends on the loan closing) away from selecting, managing, or pressuring the appraiser. Regulation Z offers a safe harbor for arrangements like this.
Getting a copy of the appraisal
- ECOA (Regulation B): For first-lien loans secured by a dwelling, notify the applicant within 3 business days of application of the right to a copy. Provide copies of all appraisals and written valuations promptly upon completion or 3 business days before consummation, whichever is earlier, at no extra charge (the lender can still charge a reasonable appraisal fee). This applies even if the loan is denied or withdrawn.
- Higher-priced mortgage loans (HPMLs): Regulation Z requires an appraisal by a certified or licensed appraiser with a physical interior inspection, a copy 3 business days before consummation, and a second appraisal (at no cost to the borrower) for certain “flipped” properties: bought by the seller within the past 90 days and resold for more than 10% more, or bought within 91–180 days and resold for more than 20% more.
Appraisal review
Lenders may check an appraisal’s quality before relying on it:
- Desk review: a reviewer examines the report and data without visiting the property
- Field review: a reviewer inspects the property (often from the outside) and the comps
- Automated tools: automated valuation models (AVMs) and collateral risk tools flag unusual values
Red flags in an appraisal: comps far from the subject or much older than typical, large or inconsistent adjustments, a value exactly equal to the sales price with little support, photos that don’t match the address, and recent sales of the same property at much lower prices. See the fraud chapter.
Numbers to memorize
| Item | Number |
|---|---|
| ECOA right-to-copy notice | Within 3 business days of application |
| Copy of appraisal | Promptly on completion or 3 business days before consummation, whichever is earlier |
| HPML flip rule: second appraisal | Resold within 90 days at more than 10% increase, or 91–180 days at more than 20% increase |
Memory tricks
- “CBS”: Comp Better, Subtract. If the comp is better, take value away from the comp.
- Match the approach to the property:
- Sales comparison = Single-family homes
- Cost = Churches and Construction (new or unique)
- Income = Investment (rental) property
- IRV for the income approach: Income ÷ Rate = Value.
Watch out on the exam
- Adjust the comp, not the subject. Any answer that adjusts the subject is wrong.
- The MLO may ask the appraiser to consider more comps or fix a factual error. That’s allowed. Telling the appraiser the “target value” is not.
- “Which approach is MOST reliable for a single-family owner-occupied home?” Sales comparison.
- External obsolescence is outside the property and can’t be fixed by the owner.
- The borrower gets a copy even if the loan is denied.
- The borrower can waive the 3-day timing for receiving the appraisal copy under ECOA, but not the right to receive it.